ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

class << self idiom in Ruby

What does class << self do in Ruby?

There is a very nice article about this topic written by Yehuda Katz: yehudakatz.com/2009/11/15/… and Yugui: yugui.jp/articles/846
Another super nice Article here: integralist.co.uk/posts/eigenclass.html
I am seeing this inside of a module, does that make it different? github.com/ruby/rake/blob/master/lib/rake/rake_module.rb
@FullDecent It does not make a difference as everything in Ruby is an object including modules and classes.

C
Chris Jester-Young

First, the class << foo syntax opens up foo's singleton class (eigenclass). This allows you to specialise the behaviour of methods called on that specific object.

a = 'foo'
class << a
  def inspect
    '"bar"'
  end
end
a.inspect   # => "bar"

a = 'foo'   # new object, new singleton class
a.inspect   # => "foo"

Now, to answer the question: class << self opens up self's singleton class, so that methods can be redefined for the current self object (which inside a class or module body is the class or module itself). Usually, this is used to define class/module ("static") methods:

class String
  class << self
    def value_of obj
      obj.to_s
    end
  end
end

String.value_of 42   # => "42"

This can also be written as a shorthand:

class String
  def self.value_of obj
    obj.to_s
  end
end

Or even shorter:

def String.value_of obj
  obj.to_s
end

When inside a function definition, self refers to the object the function is being called with. In this case, class << self opens the singleton class for that object; one use of that is to implement a poor man's state machine:

class StateMachineExample
  def process obj
    process_hook obj
  end

private
  def process_state_1 obj
    # ...
    class << self
      alias process_hook process_state_2
    end
  end

  def process_state_2 obj
    # ...
    class << self
      alias process_hook process_state_1
    end
  end

  # Set up initial state
  alias process_hook process_state_1
end

So, in the example above, each instance of StateMachineExample has process_hook aliased to process_state_1, but note how in the latter, it can redefine process_hook (for self only, not affecting other StateMachineExample instances) to process_state_2. So, each time a caller calls the process method (which calls the redefinable process_hook), the behaviour changes depending on what state it's in.


@Jörg: +1 for edit (I wish SO provides the ability to upvote edits; oh well). That indeed is the more common use of class << self, to create class/module methods. I will probably expand on that use of class << self, as that is a much more idiomatic use.
gsub!("eigenclass", "singleton class"), see the upcoming method redmine.ruby-lang.org/repositories/revision/1?rev=27022
It's really confusing to refer to a's singleton_class since a's class (after changing inspect) is a unique variant of the String class. If it were changing the singleton String class it would affect all other String instances. What's weirder still is that if you later reopen String to redefine inspect then a will still pick up the new changes.
@OldPro I still prefer the name eigenclass, as (I believe) Matz also does. But, can't please everyone, I guess.
I find the expression, "opens an object's singleton class"--which I've read many times before--vague. To my knowledge, nowhere in the Ruby docs is "opening" a class defined, even though we all have an idea of what it means. Does class << self mean anything more than the value of self is set equal to the singleton class within the block's scope?
S
Saman Mohamadi

I found a super simple explanation about class << self , Eigenclass and different type of methods.

In Ruby, there are three types of methods that can be applied to a class:

Instance methods Singleton methods Class methods

Instance methods and class methods are almost similar to their homonymous in other programming languages.

class Foo  
  def an_instance_method  
    puts "I am an instance method"  
  end  
  def self.a_class_method  
    puts "I am a class method"  
  end  
end

foo = Foo.new

def foo.a_singleton_method
  puts "I am a singletone method"
end

Another way of accessing an Eigenclass(which includes singleton methods) is with the following syntax (class <<):

foo = Foo.new

class << foo
  def a_singleton_method
    puts "I am a singleton method"
  end
end

now you can define a singleton method for self which is the class Foo itself in this context:

class Foo
  class << self
    def a_singleton_and_class_method
      puts "I am a singleton method for self and a class method for Foo"
    end
  end
end

actually Singleton methods and Class methods are the same, both of them existing in singleton class. you can use foo.singleton_class.instance_methods(false) to check.
In the first coding snippet "singleton" is spelled "singletone"
A
Arslan Ali

Usually, instance methods are global methods. That means they are available in all instances of the class on which they were defined. In contrast, a singleton method is implemented on a single object.

Ruby stores methods in classes and all methods must be associated with a class. The object on which a singleton method is defined is not a class (it is an instance of a class). If only classes can store methods, how can an object store a singleton method? When a singleton method is created, Ruby automatically creates an anonymous class to store that method. These anonymous classes are called metaclasses, also known as singleton classes or eigenclasses. The singleton method is associated with the metaclass which, in turn, is associated with the object on which the singleton method was defined.

If multiple singleton methods are defined within a single object, they are all stored in the same metaclass.

class Zen
end

z1 = Zen.new
z2 = Zen.new

class << z1
  def say_hello
    puts "Hello!"
  end
end

z1.say_hello    # Output: Hello!
z2.say_hello    # Output: NoMethodError: undefined method `say_hello'…

In the above example, class << z1 changes the current self to point to the metaclass of the z1 object; then, it defines the say_hello method within the metaclass.

Classes are also objects (instances of the built-in class called Class). Class methods are nothing more than singleton methods associated with a class object.

class Zabuton
  class << self
    def stuff
      puts "Stuffing zabuton…"
    end
  end
end

All objects may have metaclasses. That means classes can also have metaclasses. In the above example, class << self modifies self so it points to the metaclass of the Zabuton class. When a method is defined without an explicit receiver (the class/object on which the method will be defined), it is implicitly defined within the current scope, that is, the current value of self. Hence, the stuff method is defined within the metaclass of the Zabuton class. The above example is just another way to define a class method. IMHO, it's better to use the def self.my_new_clas_method syntax to define class methods, as it makes the code easier to understand. The above example was included so we understand what's happening when we come across the class << self syntax.

Additional info can be found at this post about Ruby Classes.


after review of various sources on this question, your answer really clarified everything perfectly. Thank You!
C
Community

What class << thing does:

class Hi
  self #=> Hi
  class << self #same as 'class << Hi'
    self #=> #<Class:Hi>
    self == Hi.singleton_class #=> true
  end
end

[it makes self == thing.singleton_class in the context of its block].

What is thing.singleton_class?

hi = String.new
def hi.a
end

hi.class.instance_methods.include? :a #=> false
hi.singleton_class.instance_methods.include? :a #=> true

hi object inherits its #methods from its #singleton_class.instance_methods and then from its #class.instance_methods.
Here we gave hi's singleton class instance method :a. It could have been done with class << hi instead.
hi's #singleton_class has all instance methods hi's #class has, and possibly some more (:a here).

[instance methods of thing's #class and #singleton_class can be applied directly to thing. when ruby sees thing.a, it first looks for :a method definition in thing.singleton_class.instance_methods and then in thing.class.instance_methods]

By the way - they call object's singleton class == metaclass == eigenclass.


a
artamonovdev

А singleton method is a method that is defined only for a single object.

Example:

class SomeClass
  class << self
    def test
    end
  end
end

test_obj = SomeClass.new

def test_obj.test_2
end

class << test_obj
  def test_3
  end
end

puts "Singleton's methods of SomeClass"
puts SomeClass.singleton_methods
puts '------------------------------------------'
puts "Singleton's methods of test_obj"
puts test_obj.singleton_methods

Singleton's methods of SomeClass

test

Singleton's methods of test_obj

test_2

test_3


D
Douglas G. Allen

In fact if you write any C extensions for your Ruby projects there is really only one way to define a Module method.

rb_define_singleton_method

I know this self business just opens up all kinds of other questions so you could do better by searching each part.

Objects first.

foo = Object.new

Can I make a method for foo?

Sure

def foo.hello
 'hello'
end

What do I do with it?

foo.hello
 ==>"hello"

Just another object.

foo.methods

You get all the Object methods plus your new one.

def foo.self
 self
end

foo.self

Just the foo Object.

Try to see what happens if you make foo from other Objects like Class and Module. The examples from all the answers are nice to play with but you have to work with different ideas or concepts to really understand what is going on with the way the code is written. So now you have lots of terms to go look at.

Singleton, Class, Module, self, Object, and Eigenclass was brought up but Ruby doesn't name Object Models that way. It's more like Metaclass. Richard or __why shows you the idea here. http://viewsourcecode.org/why/hacking/seeingMetaclassesClearly.html And if the blows you away then try looking up Ruby Object Model in search. Two videos that I know of on YouTube are Dave Thomas and Peter Cooper. They try to explain that concept too. It took Dave a long time to get it so don't worry. I'm still working on it too. Why else would I be here? Thanks for your question. Also take a look at the standard library. It has a Singleton Module just as an FYI.

This is pretty good. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4uiyWA8eFk