ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

How to understand nil vs. empty vs. blank in Ruby

I find myself repeatedly looking for a clear definition of the differences of nil?, blank?, and empty? in Ruby on Rails. Here's the closest I've come:

blank? objects are false, empty, or a whitespace string. For example, "", " ", nil, [], and {} are blank.

nil? objects are instances of NilClass.

empty? objects are class-specific, and the definition varies from class to class. A string is empty if it has no characters, and an array is empty if it contains no items.

Is there anything missing, or a tighter comparison that can be made?

One gotcha is an empty array returns false for present?. Which is because blank? returns true for an empty array.
One nice thing is to see that :nil? is defined on ::Kernel and overridden on ::NilClass, while :empty? is implemented separately on many classes (natively on ::String, ::Array, ::Hash, and non-natively on other classes like ::Set from stdlib and ::ActiveRecord::Relation from rails). So :nil? is available in all subclasses of ::Object and also in every class that includes ::Kernel by itself, where :empty? must be implemented or included specifically in your classes.
If you try to understand the whole nil concept start here.
[1] pry(main)> [].blank? => true

a
alhimik45

.nil? can be used on any object and is true if the object is nil.

.empty? can be used on strings, arrays and hashes and returns true if:

String length == 0

Array length == 0

Hash length == 0

Running .empty? on something that is nil will throw a NoMethodError.

That is where .blank? comes in. It is implemented by Rails and will operate on any object as well as work like .empty? on strings, arrays and hashes.

nil.blank? == true
false.blank? == true
[].blank? == true
{}.blank? == true
"".blank? == true
5.blank? == false
0.blank? == false

.blank? also evaluates true on strings which are non-empty but contain only whitespace:

"  ".blank? == true
"  ".empty? == false

Rails also provides .present?, which returns the negation of .blank?.

Array gotcha: blank? will return false even if all elements of an array are blank. To determine blankness in this case, use all? with blank?, for example:

[ nil, '' ].blank? == false
[ nil, '' ].all? &:blank? == true 

As mentioned in the question, some non-empty strings count as blank.
Why haven't they overwritter nil's .empty? if they could add .blank?
Also: false.blank? == true
I've seen blank? erroneously used in non-rails contexts before. If you really need it you can include it: require 'active_support/core_ext/object/blank'
As an addition to the all-blank-array gotcha that Tom is mentioning in his answer, be aware that this can lead to security issues where an attacker can use unprepared code that simply checks for unless params.nil? or unless params.blank?, and is the cause of much discussion and work currently in Rails. See here for more information: github.com/rails/rails/issues/13420
d
dimpiax

I made this useful table with all the cases:

https://i.stack.imgur.com/oXuhJ.png

blank?, present? are provided by Rails.


It should be noted that blank? and present? are Rails-only. They return Exception: NoMethodError in Ruby 2.0.0.
Consider adding any? if you ever update the table.
blank? and present? are not "Rails-only", they're automatically included by Rails but can easily be included in non-Rails code by using ActiveSupport's Core extensions. See stackoverflow.com/questions/4238867/…
S
Sibevin Wang

Just extend Julian's table:

https://i.stack.imgur.com/qbe46.png

Ref: empty?blank?nil?傻傻分不清楚


@Sibevin Wang, I have downloaded this table and used it in some of my answers adding the credits to you. Hope you won't mind :) Kudos to this great effort!
Enumerable#any? is vanilla Ruby, it shouldn't be listed under "rails only"
@daniero Thanks for your reminder, the table is updated.
Numeric types also have .zero? and .nonzero?
A
Alexander Malfait

Quick tip: !obj.blank? == obj.present?

Can be handy/easier on the eyes in some expressions


is there something equivalent to !obj.nil?
present? is part of active_support, check here on what to include to get it: stackoverflow.com/a/4648704/1569
@Kirk: !!obj is equivalent to !obj.nil?
@MohamedHafez No it's not. !!false
Agh, @Ajedi32 good catch! equivalent with that one exception.
s
steve

https://i.stack.imgur.com/BdN1t.png

Everything that is nil? is blank?

Everything that is empty? is blank?

Nothing that is empty? is nil?

Nothing that is nil? is empty?

tl;dr -- only use blank? & present? unless you want to distinguish between "" and " "


t
the Tin Man

One difference is that .nil? and .empty? are methods that are provided by the programming language Ruby, whereas .blank? is something added by the web development framework Rails.


A
Alan H

A special case is when trying to assess if a boolean value is nil:

false.present? == false
false.blank? == true
false.nil? == false

In this case the recommendation would be to use .nil?


d
davemyron

Just a little note about the any? recommendation: He's right that it's generally equivalent to !empty?. However, any? will return true to a string of just whitespace (ala " ").

And of course, see the 1.9 comment above, too.


In Rails, any string containing just whitespace characters is "blank": " \n\r\t".blank? #=> true
佚名

Don't forget any? which is generally !empty?. In Rails I typically check for the presence of something at the end of a statement with if something or unless something then use blank? where needed since it seems to work everywhere.


.any? doesn't work with strings in ruby 1.9, as .any? requires enumerable, and string#each by itself doesn't work in ruby 1.9.
Careful about any? for checking non-emptiness. It returns false if you have an array of falsy values. A way to get around that is to pass a always-true block: [nil, false].any?{ true }, but !empty? is shorter and you don't have remember the weird behavior.
t
the Tin Man

nil? is a standard Ruby method that can be called on all objects and returns true if the object is nil:

b = nil
b.nil? # => true

empty? is a standard Ruby method that can be called on some objects such as Strings, Arrays and Hashes and returns true if these objects contain no element:

a = []
a.empty? # => true

b = ["2","4"]
b.empty? # => false

empty? cannot be called on nil objects.

blank? is a Rails method that can be called on nil objects as well as empty objects.


t
the Tin Man

Everybody else has explained well what is the difference.

I would like to add in Ruby On Rails, it is better to use obj.blank? or obj.present? instead of obj.nil? or obj.empty?.

obj.blank? handles all types nil, '', [], {}, and returns true if values are not available and returns false if values are available on any type of object.


n
ndnenkov

exists? method can be used to check whether the data exists in the database or not. It returns boolean values either true or false.


Works only on model class!
m
mahatmanich

Rails 4

an alternative to @corban-brook 's 'Array gotcha: blank?' for checking if an arrays only holds empty values and can be regarded as blank? true:

[ nil, '' ].all? &:blank? == true

one could also do:

[nil, '', "", " ",' '].reject(&:blank?).blank? == true

v
vidur punj

Though there n-number of answers available to this question but I liked the way its being explained here so posted one more answer :-)

Look at the data metric below - Its self explanatory with the various data-types used across available methods for it.

https://i.stack.imgur.com/g4SrL.png

Reference: https://blog.appsignal.com/2018/09/11/differences-between-nil-empty-blank-and-present.html


t
the Tin Man

nil? can be used on any object. It determines if the object has any value or not, including 'blank' values.

For example:

example = nil
example.nil?  # true

"".nil?  # false

Basically nil? will only ever return true if the object is in fact equal to 'nil'.

empty? is only called on objects that are considered a collection. This includes things like strings (a collection of characters), hashes (a collection of key/value pairs) and arrays (a collection of arbitrary objects). empty? returns true is there are no items in the collection.

For example:

"".empty? # true
"hi".empty?   # false
{}.empty?  # true
{"" => ""}.empty?   # false
[].empty?   # true
[nil].empty?  # false

nil.empty?  # NoMethodError: undefined method `empty?' for nil:NilClass

Notice that empty? can't be called on nil objects as nil objects are not a collection and it will raise an exception.

Also notice that even if the items in a collection are blank, it does not mean a collection is empty.

blank? is basically a combination of nil? and empty? It's useful for checking objects that you assume are collections, but could also be nil.