ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

How to echo shell commands as they are executed

In a shell script, how do I echo all shell commands called and expand any variable names?

For example, given the following line:

ls $DIRNAME

I would like the script to run the command and display the following

ls /full/path/to/some/dir

The purpose is to save a log of all shell commands called and their arguments. Is there perhaps a better way of generating such a log?


C
Charles Duffy

set -x or set -o xtrace expands variables and prints a little + sign before the line.

set -v or set -o verbose does not expand the variables before printing.

Use set +x and set +v to turn off the above settings.

On the first line of the script, one can put #!/bin/sh -x (or -v) to have the same effect as set -x (or -v) later in the script.

The above also works with /bin/sh.

See the bash-hackers' wiki on set attributes, and on debugging.

$ cat shl
#!/bin/bash                                                                     

DIR=/tmp/so
ls $DIR

$ bash -x shl 
+ DIR=/tmp/so
+ ls /tmp/so
$

If you also want to see which numbered line is being executed see stackoverflow.com/a/17805088/1729501
what if I want to color the command when echoing to differentiate the command and its results output ?
@LewisChan : you can add a colored static or dynamic prefix, f.e. timestamp, to your commands, see stackoverflow.com/a/62620480/2693875 .
@AndreasDietrich Thanks. You'd make my day if you actually found a way to implement my joke question. Preferably with some powerful cli tools and only a few lines of code.
bash -x foo.sh was the crux of what I needed. (Posting as a comment because it wasn't immediately apparent whether that would work without modifying the script itself; it did. )
P
Peter Mortensen

set -x will give you what you want.

Here is an example shell script to demonstrate:

#!/bin/bash
set -x #echo on

ls $PWD

This expands all variables and prints the full commands before output of the command.

Output:

+ ls /home/user/
file1.txt file2.txt

Using the word "verbose" that way doesn't accomplish anything. You can do set -o verbose or set -v (only "verbose") or set -o xtrace or set -x (only "xtrace") or set -xv (both) or set -o xtrace -o verbose (both).
this works good, but be aware that the "verbose" overwrites $1
P
Peter Mortensen

I use a function to echo and run the command:

#!/bin/bash
# Function to display commands
exe() { echo "\$ $@" ; "$@" ; }

exe echo hello world

Which outputs

$ echo hello world
hello world

For more complicated commands pipes, etc., you can use eval:

#!/bin/bash
# Function to display commands
exe() { echo "\$ ${@/eval/}" ; "$@" ; }

exe eval "echo 'Hello, World!' | cut -d ' ' -f1"

Which outputs

$  echo 'Hello, World!' | cut -d ' ' -f1
Hello

Not many votes for this answer. Is there a reason it's a bad idea? Worked for me, and seems to be exactly what I'm looking for...
This is the best answer if you don't want every command printed. It avoids the ++ set +x output when turned off, as well as looking cleaner. For just a single statement or two, though, bhassel's answer using a subshell is the most convenient.
A major downside to this is that the output loses the quoting information. You can't differentiate between cp "foo bar" baz and cp foo "bar baz", for example. So it's good for displaying progress information to a user; less so for debugging output or recording reproducible commands. Different use cases. In zsh, you can preserve quoting with the :q modifier: exe() { echo '$' "${@:q}" ; "$@" ; }
I don't like this answer. There are lots of edge cases where what you see is not what you get (especially with whitespace, quotes, escaped characters, variable/expression substitutions, etc), so don't blindly paste the echoed command into a terminal and assume it will run the same way. Also, the second technique is just a hack, and will strip out other instances of the word eval from your command. So don't expect it to work properly on exe eval "echo 'eval world'"!
a drawback is that you cannot use this exe function in subshell commands like: VAR=$(exe echo "hello world"); echo $VAR The value of $VAR will be the echoed command plus the result of the command. like: 'echo hello world hello world'
P
Peter Mortensen

You can also toggle this for select lines in your script by wrapping them in set -x and set +x, for example,

#!/bin/bash
...
if [[ ! -e $OUT_FILE ]];
then
   echo "grabbing $URL"
   set -x
   curl --fail --noproxy $SERV -s -S $URL -o $OUT_FILE
   set +x
fi

But, script prints set +x too
P
Peter Mortensen

shuckc's answer for echoing select lines has a few downsides: you end up with the following set +x command being echoed as well, and you lose the ability to test the exit code with $? since it gets overwritten by the set +x.

Another option is to run the command in a subshell:

echo "getting URL..."
( set -x ; curl -s --fail $URL -o $OUTFILE )

if [ $? -eq 0 ] ; then
    echo "curl failed"
    exit 1
fi

which will give you output like:

getting URL...
+ curl -s --fail http://example.com/missing -o /tmp/example
curl failed

This does incur the overhead of creating a new subshell for the command, though.


Nice way to avoid the ++ set +x output.
Even better: replace if [ $? -eq 0 ] with if (set -x; COMMAND).
Awesome; Great answer. Thank you for your insight.
In my question someone recommended this cool solution: superuser.com/questions/806599/…
P
Peter Mortensen

According to TLDP's Bash Guide for Beginners: Chapter 2. Writing and debugging scripts:

2.3.1. Debugging on the entire script $ bash -x script1.sh ... There is now a full-fledged debugger for Bash, available at SourceForge. These debugging features are available in most modern versions of Bash, starting from 3.x. 2.3.2. Debugging on part(s) of the script set -x # Activate debugging from here w set +x # Stop debugging from here ... Table 2-1. Overview of set debugging options

    Short  | Long notation | Result
    -------+---------------+--------------------------------------------------------------
    set -f | set -o noglob | Disable file name generation using metacharacters (globbing).
    set -v | set -o verbose| Prints shell input lines as they are read.
    set -x | set -o xtrace | Print command traces before executing command.

... Alternatively, these modes can be specified in the script itself, by adding the desired options to the first line shell declaration. Options can be combined, as is usually the case with UNIX commands: #!/bin/bash -xv


P
Peter Mortensen

Another option is to put "-x" at the top of your script instead of on the command line:

$ cat ./server
#!/bin/bash -x
ssh user@server

$ ./server
+ ssh user@server
user@server's password: ^C
$

Note that this doesn't seem to work exactly the same between ./myScript and bash myScript. Still a good thing to point out, thanks.
P
Peter Mortensen

You can execute a Bash script in debug mode with the -x option.

This will echo all the commands.

bash -x example_script.sh

# Console output
+ cd /home/user
+ mv text.txt mytext.txt

You can also save the -x option in the script. Just specify the -x option in the shebang.

######## example_script.sh ###################
#!/bin/bash -x

cd /home/user
mv text.txt mytext.txt

##############################################

./example_script.sh

# Console output
+ cd /home/user
+ mv text.txt mytext.txt

Also bash -vx will do the same but without variable interpolation
This is nice, but a bit more hardcore than I wanted. It seems to "descend" into all the commands run by my top-level script. I really just wanted the commands of my top-level script to be echoed, not absolutely everything bash runs.
P
Peter Mortensen

Type "bash -x" on the command line before the name of the Bash script. For instance, to execute foo.sh, type:

bash -x foo.sh

P
Phani Rithvij

Combining all the answers I found this to be the best, simplest

# https://stackoverflow.com/a/64644990/8608146
exe(){
    set -x
    "$@"
    { set +x; } 2>/dev/null
}
# example
exe go generate ./...

{ set +x; } 2>/dev/null from https://stackoverflow.com/a/19226038/8608146

If the exit status of the command is needed, as mentioned here

Use

{ STATUS=$?; set +x; } 2>/dev/null

And use the $STATUS later like exit $STATUS at the end

A slightly more useful one

# https://stackoverflow.com/a/64644990/8608146
_exe(){
    [ $1 == on  ] && { set -x; return; } 2>/dev/null
    [ $1 == off ] && { set +x; return; } 2>/dev/null
    echo + "$@"
    "$@"
}
exe(){
    { _exe "$@"; } 2>/dev/null
}

# examples
exe on # turn on same as set -x
echo This command prints with +
echo This too prints with +
exe off # same as set +x
echo This does not

# can also be used for individual commands
exe echo what up!

Great examples. I would add #!/bin/bash to the top of both scripts.
G
Gama11

For zsh, echo

setopt VERBOSE

And for debugging,

setopt XTRACE

P
Peter Mortensen

To allow for compound commands to be echoed, I use eval plus Soth's exe function to echo and run the command. This is useful for piped commands that would otherwise only show none or just the initial part of the piped command.

Without eval:

exe() { echo "\$ $@" ; "$@" ; }
exe ls -F | grep *.txt

Outputs:

$
file.txt

With eval:

exe() { echo "\$ $@" ; "$@" ; }
exe eval 'ls -F | grep *.txt'

Which outputs

$ exe eval 'ls -F | grep *.txt'
file.txt

c
cnst

For csh and tcsh, you can set verbose or set echo (or you can even set both, but it may result in some duplication most of the time).

The verbose option prints pretty much the exact shell expression that you type.

The echo option is more indicative of what will be executed through spawning.

http://www.tcsh.org/tcsh.html/Special_shell_variables.html#verbose

http://www.tcsh.org/tcsh.html/Special_shell_variables.html#echo

Special shell variables

verbose If set, causes the words of each command to be printed, after history substitution (if any). Set by the -v command line option.

echo If set, each command with its arguments is echoed just before it is executed. For non-builtin commands all expansions occur before echoing. Builtin commands are echoed before command and filename substitution, because these substitutions are then done selectively. Set by the -x command line option.


How do you disable echo/verbose once you set it?
K
Karthik Arun
$ cat exampleScript.sh
#!/bin/bash
name="karthik";
echo $name;

bash -x exampleScript.sh

Output is as follows:

https://i.stack.imgur.com/6Rx0h.jpg


What are the colour definitions for your terminal (RGB, numerical)?