ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

window.onbeforeunload not working on the iPad?

Does anyone know if the onbeforeunload event is supported on the iPad and/or if there's a different way to use it?

I've tried pretty much everything, and it seems like the onbeforeunload event is never triggered on the iPad (Safari browser).

Specifically, this is what I've tried:

window.onbeforeunload = function(event) { event.returnValue = 'test'; }

window.onbeforeunload = function(event) { return 'test'; }

(both of the above together)

window.onbeforeunload = function(event) { alert('test')'; }

(all of the above functions but inside

All of these work on FF and Safari on the PC, but not on the iPad.

Also, I've done the following just after loading the page:

alert('onbeforeunload' in window);
alert(typeof window.onbeforeunload);
alert(window.onbeforeunload);

Respectively, the results are:

true

object

null

So, the browser does have the property, but for some reason it doesn't get fired.

The ways I try to navigate away from the page are by clicking the back and forward buttons, by doing a google search in the top bar, by changing location in the address bar, and by clicking on a bookmark.

Does anyone have any idea about what's going on? I'd greatly appreciate any input.

Thanks

Thank you both for your input. It must be one of the reasons you mentioned. Unfortunately, there's no official documentation from Apple regarding this and other limitations. Hopefully, they will come up with a more creative way of enabling this feature, while preventing malicious use of it. I hear very often that people accidentally tap away from the page and lose all the data they had entered in a form.
Have you tried using addEventListener()?
I'm pretty sure beforeunload doesn't work on Safari on iOS. :-( Perhaps not what you're looking for, but I have a suggestion for how to reliably test for a working beforeunload
On Mar 3'16, The window.onbeforeunload = function(event) { event.returnValue = 'test'; } doesn't work on both Chrome and Safari of iOS 9.2.1 . I really like onbeforeunload Because the page does not change if I click cancel.
Seems like this problem was solved in Safari and iOS 13

D
Danger

This bit of JavaScript works for me on Safari and Chrome on ipad and iphone, as well as desktop/laptop/other browsers:

var isOnIOS = navigator.userAgent.match(/iPad/i)|| navigator.userAgent.match(/iPhone/i);
var eventName = isOnIOS ? "pagehide" : "beforeunload";

window.addEventListener(eventName, function (event) { 
    window.event.cancelBubble = true; // Don't know if this works on iOS but it might!
    ...
} );

It can catch the event, but how can you pop up the confirmation prompt? Using return 'test'; similar to that by op isn't working..
Thanks I missed that in the original question. I haven't specifically tested this on iOS, but possibly adding this additional line would work: window.event.cancelBubble = true; I'll add to my answer
Thanks, but sadly it does not work... I tried to put alert() inside it, seems the new page has begun to load before the alert() is fired. Also see this: stackoverflow.com/questions/3239834/…
guys, did you find any solution to show the confirmation prompt before leaving page? This works fine in every browser except IOS safari. I tried pagehide event too, but didn't work for me. Thanks in advance.
I've tested multiple workarounds and I'm pretty sure it's not possible to show the confirmation prompt when on iOS, regardless of the browser used.
D
Danny Armstrong

I have found that the onunload() event does fire. It's behavior is somewhat odd; whatever you have in your callback function attached to the event is actually run after the new page has loaded in the background (You can't tell it's loaded yet, but server logging will show that it has).

More oddly, if you have a confirm() call in your onunload(), and the user has clicked a link to go somewhere else, you are in business. If, however, the user closes the iPad Safari browser tab, the onunload() event will fire, but your confirm() will have an implicit cancel as response.


Huh, seems this confirm quirk (that the second page is hit before the confirm message) is true not just for mobile safari but for firefox (and probably others) as well. You just blew my mind.
unload event deprecated in favor of pagehide see developer.apple.com/library/ios/documentation/AppleApplications/…
@sol0mka: That’s it, man! Great! In my case the following code did the job, so far as I can see for all my browsers AND iOS: $(window).on('beforeunload pagehide', function() { // my stuff that has to be done on page change } ); This should be the accepted answer in my eyes.
It shoud be noted that, under certain conditions, the unload, beforeunload and pagehide events may not fire reliably by the browser. For example, pagehide will not fire if a mobile user closes the browser app via the app manager. Source: developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Window/pagehide_event
C
Charles Boyung

Only Apple would know for sure, but my guess is that they purposely did not enable that functionality in mobile Safari because it is most often used by shady characters to get you to stay on their site or pop up lots of porn/advertising windows.


Or, you know, save your changes automatically so they aren't lost just because you accidentally tapped the wrong thing.
I didn't say there weren't valid uses, I just said that those were the most often uses.
@JoelMueller Your comment should be the accepted answer :)
@JoelMueller That is exactly my use case. Grrr @ apple
@JoelMueller can you please share any official doc where we can address this statement that mobile safari saves changes automatically.
J
Joel Mueller

There's a known bug in WebKit with onbeforeunload. I believe it's fixed in the latest beta of Chrome 5, but it's quite possible the iPad's browser is made from a version of WebKit that doesn't have the fix.

Related Chrome bug report.


I'm I confused or does this bug still exist on the iPad browser?
J
Julien Bachmann

beforeunload event is not supported by Mobile Safari. You can see the list of all supported events here: Handling Events Apple documentation

And the beforeunload is not in the list!


z
zelda.j

https://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=97035

see hear.

alerts are no longer allowed during page dismissal events (beforeunload, unload, pagehide).

I think alerts, prompt, confirm, and other actions like these are also no longer allowed.


D
Dan Bray

Here's a solution that should work on all modern browsers:

var unloaded = false;
window.addEventListener("beforeunload", function(e)
{
    if (unloaded)
        return;
    unloaded = true;
    console.log("beforeUnload");
});
window.addEventListener("visibilitychange", function(e)
{
    if (document.visibilityState == 'hidden')
    {
        if (unloaded)
            return;
        unloaded = true;
        console.log("beforeUnload");
    }
});

Mobile browsers don't tend to not support beforeunload because the browser can go into the background without unloading the page, then be killed by the operating system at any time.

Most desktop browser contain a bug that causes visibilityState to not get called when the document unloads. See: here.

Therefore, it's important to include both events to cover all scenarios.

NB

I have used console.log instead of alert in my example because alert will get blocked by some browsers when called from beforeunload or visibilitychange.


M
Miquel

If you just need to know if the page has been left you can use document.unload. It works fine in ios browsers. If you see on Apple documentation you'll find that it's deprecated and they recommend to use document.pagehide


yes, this event fires in safari, but confirmation prompt is not coming as in chrome.