ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

Why does integer division yield a float instead of another integer?

Consider this division in Python:

Python 3.1 (r31:73574, Jun 26 2009, 20:21:35) [MSC v.1500 32 bit (Intel)] on win32
Type "help", "copyright", "credits" or "license" for more information.
>>> 2/2
1.0

Is this intended? I strongly remember earlier versions returning int/int = int. What should I do? Is there a new division operator or must I always cast?

Yes, that's the way division works in 3.x.
Here's a post by Python's creator talking about how the rounding works, it's orthogonal to your question but I found it interesting: python-history.blogspot.com/2010/08/…
@hughdbrown so that means for all python 3 version essentially?
@hughdbrown: yes, PEP is final, meaning both accepted and implemented.
If you are doing anything other than simple division, then casting the float result is a better method. For example, calculating 480 // 640 * 320 results in 0

B
Brandon E Taylor

Take a look at PEP-238: Changing the Division Operator

The // operator will be available to request floor division unambiguously.


@JonathanSternberg except for all the code that was written for python 2.0. I feel like the role of / and // should be reversed to keep backwards compatibility. Also, in pretty much every other language / preserves type. i would make more sense then for // to automatically convert to float, not /.
The second part (after the "Also") makes sense (similarity to other languages) but regarding the first part, the whole point of Python 3 was to NOT be backwards compatible with Python 2, but rather fix up a bunch of problems with Python 2. Enough people found the ambiguity of / to be enough of a language design "mistake" that needed to be fixed in Python 3. It may have been a controversial decision, but enough people felt it was the correct one. Count me in the group that loves the change. It is nice we can all agree to disagree. Cheers. :)
T
TylerH

Oops, immediately found 2//2. This will output an int rather than a float.


This seems to not work for negative numbers. -1//5 return -1 and -5//5 returns -1.
@mschuett: this is to be expected, and is the same result as with Python 2.
Yeah I did some more digging and found that out as well. However I would imagine a decent size number of people do not realize this depending on the language they come from.
@TylerH I doubt there was any confusion in the past 12 years that warranted your edit?
@JonasByström The upvoted comments asking for clarification and giving that clarification weren't a clue? Hard to see how one wouldn't see an obvious opportunity for improvement from the original version of the answer. Good answers provide the solution and an explanation of said solution. Readers might otherwise use // instead of / because of this answer and cause code that depends on a float to break, not realizing the implications.
P
Peter Mortensen

Behavior of the division operator in Python 2.7 and Python 3

In Python 2.7: By default, division operator will return integer output.

To get the result in double, multiply the dividend or divisor by 1.0.

100/35 => 2 # Expected is 2.857142857142857
(100*1.0)/35 => 2.857142857142857
100/(35*1.0) => 2.857142857142857

In Python 3

// => used for integer output
/ => used for double output

100/35 => 2.857142857142857
100//35 => 2
100.//35 => 2.0    # Floating-point result if the divisor or dividend is real

By the way, no need to multiply by 1.0. It is enough that one of the numbers is a float. E.g., 100/35.0 = 100.0/35 = 2.857142857142857
// is not "used for integer output". // is the result of the floor() function to the result of the division, which in turns yields an integer if the two operands are integers and a float if at least one of them is a float, for types coherence.
c
code_onkel

The accepted answer already mentions PEP 238. I just want to add a quick look behind the scenes for those interested in what's going on without reading the whole PEP.

Python maps operators like +, -, * and / to special functions, such that e.g. a + b is equivalent to

a.__add__(b)

Regarding division in Python 2, there is by default only / which maps to __div__ and the result is dependent on the input types (e.g. int, float).

Python 2.2 introduced the __future__ feature division, which changed the division semantics the following way (TL;DR of PEP 238):

/ maps to __truediv__ which must "return a reasonable approximation of the mathematical result of the division" (quote from PEP 238)

// maps to __floordiv__, which should return the floored result of /

With Python 3.0, the changes of PEP 238 became the default behaviour and there is no more special method __div__ in Python's object model.

If you want to use the same code in Python 2 and Python 3 use

from __future__ import division

and stick to the PEP 238 semantics of / and //.


T
TylerH

According to Python 3 documentation, Python when divided by integer, will generate float despite expected to be integer.

For exclusively printing integer,use floor division method. Floor division is rounding off zero and removing decimal point. Represented by //

Hence, instead of 2/2 ,use 2//2

You can also import division from __future__ irrespective of using Python 2 or Python 3.