ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

Overflow-x:hidden doesn't prevent content from overflowing in mobile browsers

I have a website here.

Viewed in a desktop browser, the black menu bar properly extends only to edge of the window, since the body has overflow-x:hidden.

In any mobile browser, whether Android or iOS, the black menu bar displays its full width, which brings whitespace on the right of the page. As far as I can tell, this whitespace isn't even a part of the html or body tags.

Even if I set the viewport to a specific width in the <head>:

<meta name="viewport" content="width=1100, initial-scale=1">

The site expands to the 1100px but still has the whitespace beyond the 1100.

What am I missing? How do I keep the viewport to 1100 and cut off the overflow?

This is especially an issue in iOS9

C
Chuck Le Butt

Creating a site wrapper div inside the <body> and applying the overflow-x:hidden to the wrapper instead of the <body> or <html> fixed the issue.

It appears that browsers that parse the <meta name="viewport"> tag simply ignore overflow attributes on the html and body tags.

Note: You may also need to add position: relative to the wrapper div.


I found that in addition to setting the overflow to hidden, I had to set the position to fixed...
Adding position to fixed stops me from being able to scroll!
I tried, I put all my code inside a div and give it overflow-x:hidden but doens't work, I add too but nothing changed :/ any ideas?
@leepowers overflow-x: hidden is still not working for me even after I add this meta tag. Could you please share a link to your website where it is working?
Hey gang, when I found that position:relative works as well.
Đ
Đinh Carabus

try

html, body {
  overflow-x:hidden 
} 

instead of just

body {
  overflow-x:hidden 
}

Thanks, but the application of overflow anything to html and/or body in any combination didn't solve the issue.
Sorry that it didn't work out for you. Before I answered I made a quick test using your site and applying my suggestion to your css. It fixed the problem for the standard- and dolphin browser on my android phone at least.
Worked for me. eduardd.eu/projects/ezo ( between 480 and 992px footer had a problem with that overflowing image of the woman and towels )
Does anyone know why this works, when specifying body{} and html{} separately doesnt?
In needed to add height:100%; as well, otherwise vertical scroll would not work properly on pages with loading images (which make the page grow in height).
C
Community

VictorS's comment on the accepted answer deserves to be it's own answer because it's a very elegant solution that does, indeed work. And I'll add a tad to it's usefulness.

Victor notes adding position:fixed works.

body.modal-open {
    overflow: hidden;
    position: fixed;
}

And indeed it does. However, it also has a slight side-affect of essentially scrolling to the top. position:absolute resolves this but, re-introduces the ability to scroll on mobile.

If you know your viewport (my plugin for adding viewport to the <body>) you can just add a css toggle for the position.

body.modal-open {
    // block scroll for mobile;
    // causes underlying page to jump to top;
    // prevents scrolling on all screens
    overflow: hidden;
    position: fixed;
}
body.viewport-lg {
    // block scroll for desktop;
    // will not jump to top;
    // will not prevent scroll on mobile
    position: absolute; 
}

I also add this to prevent the underlying page from jumping left/right when showing/hiding modals.

body {
    // STOP MOVING AROUND!
    overflow-x: hidden;
    overflow-y: scroll !important;
}

Is there anyway to get the mobile part to not jump to top?
What worked for me was turning the element that was supposed to be hidden by overflow from position: absolute to position: fixed. Thankfully.
@WraithKenny - If you want the page to prevent jumping to the top on a mobile device, you can use the following hack'ish/ugly approach. Inside your modal function, make sure you get the current scroll offset before doing anything, than apply the modal style together and also set the top margin of your body equal to the minus of the current offset. Make sure when you remove the modal you, set the margin back to 0 and scroll the page back to the original offset.
This solution only works in case your modal's content fits into the screen, i.e. you don't require to scroll the modal itself.
There are other fixed and absolute positioned elements on my page as well. Making body position:fixed or absolute disturbing their positions as well. Not suitable/working in my case :(
f
feidtmb

As @Indigenuity states, this appears to be caused by browsers parsing the <meta name="viewport"> tag.

To solve this problem at the source, try the following:

<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1, minimum-scale=1">.

In my tests this prevents the user from zooming out to view the overflowed content, and as a result prevents panning/scrolling to it as well.


Adding initial-scale=1 to an existing viewport metatag does indeed fix the problem. Thanks!
For me it was the minimum-scale=1 that fixed it
This is what actually worked for me after trying everything else. Thanks a lot !
It helps, but not preventing horizontal scrollbar on mobile yet.
Wew, thanks for this. This happened in my case. Only on media queries the whitespaces appear on bottom and right side. You bro deserve a million + and thanks
W
Waltur Buerk

This is the simplest solution to solve horisontal scrolling in Safari.

html, body {
  position:relative;
  overflow-x:hidden;
}

It seems to work. But do you have an explanation why this works?
No, it finally didn't work. I ended up doing the math and made sure that div's aren't wider than allowed, css calc() helped me here a lot as it allows the mixture of relative widths (vw or %) and absolute widths (px).
This is the only thing that helped me hide an absolutely positioned element which animates offscreen
I can't believe this is still a problem in 2019. But the solution above totally worked. Thx.
A problem with setting overflow-x: hidden on body is that position: sticky stops working.
o
ollio
body{
height: 100%;
overflow: hidden !important;
width: 100%;
position: fixed;

works on iOS9


It does work, but putting position:fixed to your body does make you scroll to top
Weird but it worked for me without fixed position, also. Only one from all the solutions here!
Only one that worked for me, using chrom and boostrap + angularJS
A
Anne

Keep the viewport untouched: <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0">

Assuming you would like to achieve the effect of a continuous black bar to the right side: #menubar shouldn't exceed 100%, adjust the border radius such that the right side is squared and adjust the padding so that it extends a little more to the right. Modify the following to your #menubar:

border-radius: 30px 0px 0px 30px;
width: 100%; /*setting to 100% would leave a little space to the right */
padding: 0px 0px 0px 10px; /*fills the little gap*/

Adjusting the padding to 10px of course leaves the left menu to the edge of the bar, you can put the remaining 40px to each of the li, 20px on each side left and right:

.menuitem {
display: block;
padding: 0px 20px;
}

When you resize the browser smaller, you would find still the white background: place your background texture instead from your div to body. Or alternatively, adjust the navigation menu width from 100% to lower value using media queries. There are a lot of adjustments to be made to your code to create a proper layout, I'm not sure what you intend to do but the above code will somehow fix your overflowing bar.


if you use box-sizing: border-box; you can add padding to a 100% width div.
I
Isaac F

Creating a site wrapper div inside the body and applying the overflow->x:hidden to the wrapper INSTEAD of the body or html fixed the issue.

This worked for me after also adding position: relative to the wrapper.


This worked for me. The side effect was that I've got two scroll bars instead of one. The solution was to make it overflow: hidden instead of overflow-x: hidden. Works on mobile Safari, Chrome, IE11 on OSX and Win.
M
MBurnette

Adding a wrapper <div> around the entirety of your content will indeed work. While semantically "icky", I added an div with a class of overflowWrap right inside the body tag and then set set my CSS like this:

html, body, .overflowWrap {
overflow-x: hidden;
}

Might be overkill now, but works like a charm!


K
Kwok Pan Fung

I encountered the same problem with Android devices but not iOS devices. Managed to resolve by specifying position:relative in the outer div of the absolutely positioned elements (with overflow:hidden for outer div)


s
spaghetticode

No previous single solution worked for me, I had to mix them and got the issue fixed also on older devices (iphone 3).

First, I had to wrap the html content into an outer div:

<html>
  <body>
    <div id="wrapper">... old html goes here ...</div>
  </body>
</html>

Then I had to apply overflow hidden to the wrapper, because overflow-x was not working:

  #wrapper {
    overflow: hidden;
  }

and this fixed the issue.


How is this different to @Indigenuity's answer?
@ian Kemp overflow: hidden != overflow-x: hidden
C
Chuck Le Butt

I solved the issue by using overflow-x:hidden; as follows

@media screen and (max-width: 441px){

#end_screen { (NOte:-the end_screen is the wrapper div for all other div's inside it.)
  overflow-x: hidden;
   }
 }

structure is as follows

1st div end_screen >> inside it >> end_screen_2(div) >> inside it >> end_screen_2.

'end_screen is the wrapper of end_screen_1 and end_screen_2 div's


S
Skylin R

As subarachnid said overflow-x hidden for both body and html worked Here's working example

**HTML**
<div class="contener">
  <div class="menu">
  das
  </div>
  <div class="hover">
    <div class="img1">
    First Strip
    </div>
     <div class="img2">
    Second Strip
    </div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="baner">
dsa
</div>

**CSS**
body, html{
  overflow-x:hidden;
}
body{
  margin:0;
}
.contener{
  width:100vw;
}
.baner{
   background-image: url("http://p3cdn4static.sharpschool.com/UserFiles/Servers/Server_3500628/Image/abstract-art-mother-earth-1.jpg");
   width:100vw;
   height:400px;
   margin-left:0;
   left:0;
}
.contener{
  height:100px;
}
.menu{
  display:flex;
  background-color:teal;
  height:100%;
  justify-content:flex-end;
  align:content:bottom;
}
.img1{
  width:150px;
  height:25px;
  transform:rotate(45deg);
  background-color:red;
  position:absolute;
  top:40px;
  right:-50px;
  line-height:25px;
  padding:0 20px;
  cursor:pointer;
  color:white;
  text-align:center;
  transition:all 0.4s;
}
.img2{
  width:190px;
  text-align:center;
  transform:rotate(45deg);
  background-color:#333;
  position:absolute;
  height:25px;
  line-height:25px;
  top:55px;
  right:-50px;
  padding:0 20px;
  cursor:pointer;
  color:white;
  transition:all 0.4s;
}
.hover{
  overflow:hidden;
}
.hover:hover .img1{
  background-color:#333;
  transition:all 0.4s;
}
.hover:hover .img2{
  background-color:blue;
  transition:all 0.4s;
}

Link


j
j.limjinda

I had tried many ways from replies in this topic, mostly works but got some side-effect like if I use overflow-x on body,html it might slow/freeze the page when users scroll down on mobile.

use position: fixed on wrapper/div inside the body is good too, but when I have a menu and use Javascript click animated scroll to some section, It's not working.

So, I decided to use touch-action: pan-y pinch-zoom on wrapper/div inside the body. Problem solved.


P
Phakamani Xulu

easiest way to solve this , add

<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, user-scalable=no, initial-scale=1.0, maximum-scale=1.0, minimum-scale=1.0">


You should absolutely never prevent the user from zooming.
h
highfellow

I've just been working on this for a few hours, trying various combinations of things from this and other pages. The thing that worked for me in the end was to make a site wrapper div, as suggested in the accepted answer, but to set both overflows to hidden instead of just the x overflow. If I leave overflow-y at scroll, I end up with a page that only scrolls vertically by a few pixels and then stops.

#all-wrapper {
  overflow: hidden;
}

Just this was enough, without setting anything on the body or html elements.


T
Tobias

The only way to fix this issue for my bootstrap modal (containing a form) was to add the following code to my CSS:

.modal {
    -webkit-overflow-scrolling: auto!important;
}

D
Dhiraj Baruah

step 1: set position to fixed to the element that goes out from the viewport. In my case it is:

.nav-links {
    position:fixed;
    right:0px;
    background-color:rgba(0,0,0, 0.8);
    height:85vh;
    top:8vh;
    display:flex;
    flex-direction:column;
    align-items: center;
    width:40%;
    transform: translateX(100%);
    transition: transform 0.5s ease-in;
}

Step2: add a css property to body and html as:

body, html{
    overflow-x:  hidden;
}

I didn't add any wrapper. Only these two steps worked for me. The project I am working on is an angular project.


J
Jason Howard

The following works

body,
.innerbodywrapper{
overflow-x: hidden;
position: fixed;
width: 100%;
height: 100vh;
}