ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

What is the difference between the | and || or operators?

I have always used || (two pipes) in OR expressions, both in C# and PHP. Occasionally I see a single pipe used: |. What is the difference between those two usages? Are there any caveats when using one over the other or are they interchangeable?


Z
Zze

Just like the & and && operator, the double Operator is a "short-circuit" operator.

For example:

if(condition1 || condition2 || condition3)

If condition1 is true, condition 2 and 3 will NOT be checked.

if(condition1 | condition2 | condition3)

This will check conditions 2 and 3, even if 1 is already true. As your conditions can be quite expensive functions, you can get a good performance boost by using them.

There is one big caveat, NullReferences or similar problems. For example:

if(class != null && class.someVar < 20)

If class is null, the if-statement will stop after class != null is false. If you only use &, it will try to check class.someVar and you get a nice NullReferenceException. With the Or-Operator that may not be that much of a trap as it's unlikely that you trigger something bad, but it's something to keep in mind.

No one ever uses the single & or | operators though, unless you have a design where each condition is a function that HAS to be executed. Sounds like a design smell, but sometimes (rarely) it's a clean way to do stuff. The & operator does "run these 3 functions, and if one of them returns false, execute the else block", while the | does "only run the else block if none return false" - can be useful, but as said, often it's a design smell.

There is a Second use of the | and & operator though: Bitwise Operations.


E
Evan Shaw

|| is the logical OR operator. It sounds like you basically know what that is. It's used in conditional statements such as if, while, etc.

condition1 || condition2

Evaluates to true if either condition1 OR condition2 is true.

| is the bitwise OR operator. It's used to operate on two numbers. You look at each bit of each number individually and, if one of the bits is 1 in at least one of the numbers, then the resulting bit will be 1 also. Here are a few examples:

A = 01010101
B = 10101010
A | B = 11111111

A = 00000001
B = 00010000
A | B = 00010001

A = 10001011
B = 00101100

A | B = 10101111

Hopefully that makes sense.

So to answer the last two questions, I wouldn't say there are any caveats besides "know the difference between the two operators." They're not interchangeable because they do two completely different things.


This helped me understand how someone was using bitwise OR operator to merge filters in Mongodb C# driver. gist.github.com/a3dho3yn/…
"It's used to operate on two numbers" This is an inaccurate/incomplete description. if (true | false) is perfectly valid in C#.
R
Rui Jarimba

One is a "bitwise or".

10011b | 01000b => 11011b

The other is a logic or.

true or false => true


| can be used on bool types as well without short circuiting.
For anyone not familiar with bitwise operators, the result example is obtained because each bit row from each column is tested against the other using OR comparison. docs.microsoft.com/en-us/cpp/c-language/c-bitwise-operators
k
krobelusmeetsyndra

Good question. These two operators work the same in PHP and C#.

| is a bitwise OR. It will compare two values by their bits. E.g. 1101 | 0010 = 1111. This is extremely useful when using bit options. E.g. Read = 01 (0X01) Write = 10 (0X02) Read-Write = 11 (0X03). One useful example would be opening files. A simple example would be:

File.Open(FileAccess.Read | FileAccess.Write);  //Gives read/write access to the file

|| is a logical OR. This is the way most people think of OR and compares two values based on their truth. E.g. I am going to the store or I will go to the mall. This is the one used most often in code. For example:

if(Name == "Admin" || Name == "Developer") { //allow access } //checks if name equals Admin OR Name equals Developer

PHP Resource: http://us3.php.net/language.operators.bitwise

C# Resources: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/kxszd0kx(VS.71).aspx

http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/6373h346(VS.71).aspx


FWIW, Technically, in C# | is a logical or when applied to booleans. As your linked reference states. In practice, the end result is the same as if it were a bitwise operator, because the bitwise values of true and false are such that a bitwise or of their values produces the exact same result as a logical or does. That is (int)(bool1 | bool2) == ((int)bool1) | ((int)bool2).
B
Bhai Saab

& - (Condition 1 & Condition 2): checks both cases even if first one is false

&& - (Condition 1 && Condition 2): dosen't bother to check second case if case one is false

&& - operator will make your code run faster, professionally & is rarely used

| - (Condition 1 | Condition 2): checks both cases even if case 1 is true

|| - (Condition 1 || Condition 2): dosen't bother to check second case if first one is true

|| - operator will make your code run faster, professionally | is rarely used


rarely used? All depends on what you want or need to do.
Great! Short and sweet, I would remove the "| is rarely used" and "& is rarely used" because, as Emaborsa said, its really depends on what you want or need to do.
I rely on bitwise operations quite heavily. These specific operators are also useful when dealing with flags. You're mistaking people rarely use them with I rarely use them.
Is rarely used means is rarely the appropriate operator, because in all possible cases an "or" operation should short-circuit.
v
vishesh

Simple example in java

public class Driver {

  static int x;
  static int y;

public static void main(String[] args) 
throws Exception {

System.out.println("using double pipe");
    if(setX() || setY())
        {System.out.println("x = "+x);
        System.out.println("y = "+y);
        }



System.out.println("using single pipe");
if(setX() | setY())
    {System.out.println("x = "+x);
    System.out.println("y = "+y);
    }

}

 static boolean setX(){
      x=5;
     return true;
  }
 static boolean setY(){
      y=5;
      return true;
  }
}

output :

using double pipe
x = 5
y = 0
using single pipe
x = 5
y = 5

Why would you give a java example for a question that doesn't even mention java?
D
Dragos Bandur

By their mathematical definition, OR and AND are binary operators; they verify the LHS and RHS conditions regardless, similarly to | and &.

|| and && alter the properties of the OR and AND operators by stopping them when the LHS condition isn't fulfilled.


T
Tharindu Vindula

For bitwise | and Logicall ||

OR

bitwise & and logicall &&

it means if( a>b | a==0) in this first left a>b will be evaluated and then a==0 will be evaluated then | operation will be done

but in|| if a>b then if wont check for next RHS

Similarly for & and &&

if(A>0 & B>0)

it will evalue LHS and then RHS then do bitwise & but

in(A>0 && B>0)

if(A>0) is false(LHS) it will directly return false;


c
codeLes

The single pipe, |, is one of the bitwise operators.

From Wikipedia:

In the C programming language family, the bitwise OR operator is "|" (pipe). Again, this operator must not be confused with its Boolean "logical or" counterpart, which treats its operands as Boolean values, and is written "||" (two pipes).


h
homeskillet

The | operator performs a bitwise OR of its two operands (meaning both sides must evaluate to false for it to return false) while the || operator will only evaluate the second operator if it needs to.

http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/kxszd0kx(VS.71).aspx

http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/6373h346(VS.71).aspx


If you actually read those articles, you would have seen that they are referring to bitwise operators
That's not what bitwise means.
K
Kyle Cronin

The singe pipe "|" is the "bitwise" or and should only be used when you know what you're doing. The double pipe "||" is a logical or, and can be used in logical statements, like "x == 0 || x == 1".

Here's an example of what the bitwise or does: if a=0101 and b=0011, then a|b=0111. If you're dealing with a logic system that treats any non-zero as true, then the bitwise or will act in the same way as the logical or, but it's counterpart (bitwise and, "&") will NOT. Also the bitwise or does not perform short circuit evaluation.


'|' can also be used on bool types without short circuiting.
D
Dane

A single pipe (|) is the bitwise OR operator.

Two pipes (||) is the logical OR operator.

They are not interchangeable.


If you ignore the bitwise operation, double pipe is lazy evaluation and single pipe is greedy, within logical operator area.