ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

Git error: "Host Key Verification Failed" when connecting to remote repository

I am trying to connect to a remote Git repository that resides on my web server and clone it to my machine.

I am using the following format for my command:

git clone ssh://username@domain.example/repository.git

This has worked fine for most of my team members. Usually after running this command Git will prompt for the user's password, and then run the cloning. However, when running on one of my machines I get the following error:

Host key verification failed. fatal: Could not read from remote repository.

We are not using SSH keys to connect to this repository, so I'm not sure why Git is checking for one on this particular machine.

You are using SSH to connect to this repository, notice how your URL begins with ssh://

B
Boris Verkhovskiy

As I answered previously in Cloning git repo causes error - Host key verification failed. fatal: The remote end hung up unexpectedly, add GitHub to the list of known hosts:

ssh-keyscan -t rsa github.com >> ~/.ssh/known_hosts

This is the most secure way, short of already having the key present. That's assuming you only run it once, not every time you connect to the server.
My company's private fit repository is using ecdsa as key, so if the solution isn't working, maybe it is because the algorithm isn't correct
This should be the accepted answer. Thanks for saving my day.
If you're using Windows, the easiest is to install git-for-windows(download) and open Git Bash . Inside this console you can use the ssh-keyscan command
You don't know how many years of frustration your answer could save. It also fixed the authentication errors of github desktop. I need to try it with my flu as well XD
S
Stephen Ostermiller

You are connecting via the SSH protocol, as indicated by the ssh:// prefix on your clone URL. Using SSH, every host has a key. Clients remember the host key associated with a particular address and refuse to connect if a host key appears to change. This prevents man in the middle attacks.

The host key for domain.example has changed. If this does not seem fishy to you, remove the old key from your local cache by editing ${HOME}/.ssh/known_hosts to remove the line for domain.example or letting an SSH utility do it for you with

ssh-keygen -R domain.example

From here, record the updated key either by doing it yourself with

ssh-keyscan -t rsa domain.example >> ~/.ssh/known_hosts

or, equivalently, let ssh do it for you next time you connect with git fetch, git pull, or git push (or even a plain ol’ ssh domain.example) by answering yes when prompted

The authenticity of host 'domain.example (a.b.c.d)' can't be established.
RSA key fingerprint is XX:XX:...:XX.
Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)?

The reason for this prompt is domain.example is no longer in your known_hosts after deleting it and presumably not in the system’s /etc/ssh/ssh_known_hosts, so ssh has no way to know whether the host on the other end of the connection is really domain.example. (If the wrong key is in /etc, someone with administrative privileges will have to update the system-wide file.)

I strongly encourage you to consider having users authenticate with keys as well. That way, ssh-agent can store key material for convenience (rather than everyone having to enter her password for each connection to the server), and passwords do not go over the network.


Fun fact, running sudo ssh-keygen -R domain.com can rename your existing known_hosts file to be known_hosts.old, and create a copy that is only readable by root. (-rw------- root root) You can easily chown this back to the appropriate user, but you also might waste an afternoon debugging why git is broken. :D
Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)?. Don't make the same mistake as me. You need to type yes. Simply hitting enter doesn't select yes by default
For CI environments, like Jenkins, you can not asnwer yes when prompted to. So, make sure that: 1. you have the ssh keys correctly created and in the .ssh dir inside your home. 2. the target domain added to known_hosts as stated here.
One gotcha is that you might need the port number for the remote repository: ssh-keyscan -p 8888 -t rsa domain.com >> ~/.ssh/known_hosts
@AndrewRueckert one of the many reasons why randomly adding sudo to the beginning of commands is a bad idea.
O
Own Rodriguez

I had the similar issue, but, using SSH keys. From Tupy's answer, above, I figured out that the issue is with known_hosts file not being present or github.com not being present in the list of known hosts. Here are the steps I followed to resolve it -

mkdir -p ~/.ssh ssh-keyscan -t rsa github.com >> ~/.ssh/known_hosts ssh-keygen -t rsa -C "user.email" open the public key with this command $ cat ~/.ssh/id_rsa.pub and copy it. Add the id_rsa.pub key to SSH keys list on your GitHub profile.


@OJFord FYI: I have edited the original answer in a way that makes your comment obsolete. TBH and with all due respect it wasn't entirely correct in the first place. The touch command would fail in case ~/.ssh directory does not exist, so step 1 was still required. Also you don't need to touch the file before using >> redirection. It will be created if necessary (but just the file, not entire path, so still mkdir -p is needed). The -p option make it work in case the directory already exists.
It's the #2 ssh-keyscan that's missing from the Github docs on adding a new ssh key.
I was having issues with my Dockerfile having a lack of permission. Adding the 2nd step here fixed that problem! Thank you for the great work
I followed the above step and failed as I was giving github.com as the hostKey in spring config server properties files. Those who are failing to connect spring.cloud.config-server to fetch from git, see this tranhoangminh.wordpress.com/2018/09/14/…. Well explained here.
P
Powderham

This is happening because github is not currently in your known hosts.

You should be prompted to add github to your known hosts. If this hasn't happened, you can run ssh -T git@github.com to receive the prompt again.


This is the right answer if you never get prompted.
Vscode suddenly giving me the titled error for no reason. Simply using this answer works for me.
C
Code-Apprentice

For me, I just had to type "yes" at the prompt which asks "Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)?" rather than just pressing Enter.


This answer lead me to realize I had to manually clone my repo on my build server in order to type 'yes' and get my bitbucket server added to my known_hosts
@Sashah If all you need is the bitbucket server in known_hosts, you can edit the file manually. No need to clone the repo if this is the only reason to do so.
Wow, I was stuck on this for the past hour and this solved it. Thank you!
k
kenorb

If you are in office intranet (otherwise dangerous) which is always protected by firewalls simply have the following lines in your ~/.ssh/config.

Host *
  StrictHostKeyChecking no
  UserKnownHostsFile=/dev/null

This is still dangerous, with our without corporate firewalls. How do you know you're talking to the real github without verifying the server key?
In corporate environments local git repos are mostly used, never opensource one. Worst case .ssh config at the top of the file can have github explicit host related config lines for ssh to choose more specific matches.
G
Geoffroy

I got the same problem on a newly installed system, but this was a udev problem. There was no /dev/tty node, so I had to do:

mknod -m 666 /dev/tty c 5 0

It worked for me because /dev/tty was created as a file, very odd! (so you have to remove it then recreate it with mknod)
@Geoffroy , I removed /dev/tty and now when do sudo , I face this error : sudo: sorry, you must have a tty to run sudo
@xe4me I never said you should remove it, depending on the system it is actually required. Reboot should fix it.
@Geoffroy , actually the first commentator , said I have to remove and the recreate :d Nope , rebooting didn't work , I had to tell the root , he fixed it :d
V
Victor Bruce

When asked:

Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)?

Type yes as the response

That is how I solved my issue. But if you try to just hit the enter button, it won't work!


g
ghiscoding

What worked for me was to first add my SSH key of the new computer, I followed these instructions from GitLab - add SSH key. Note that since I'm on Win10, I had to do all these commands in Git Bash on Windows (it didn't work in regular DOS cmd Shell).

Then again in Git Bash, I had to do a git clone of the repo that I had problems with, and in my case I had to clone it to a different name since I already had it locally and didn't want to lose my commits. For example

git clone ssh://git@gitServerUrl/myRepo.git myRepo2

Then I got the prompt to add it to known hosts list, the question might be this one:

Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)?

I typed "yes" and it finally worked, you should typically get a message similar to this:

Warning: Permanently added '[your repo link]' (ECDSA) to the list of known hosts.

Note: if you are on Windows, make sure that you use Git Bash for all the commands, this did not work in regular cmd shell or powershell, I really had to do this in Git Bash.

Lastly I deleted the second clone repo (myRepo2 in the example) and went back to my first repo and I could finally do all the Git stuff like normal in my favorite editor VSCode.


Indeed, my Cygwin prompt looks nearly exactly like my git bash prompt, but it only works in the git bash prompt!
S
Sandy

When the remote server wants to connect to the private repo, it would authenticate via ssh. Create the private-public key pair with ssh-keygen or if you already have the public-private key. copy&paste the public key in the Settings of the private repo.

YourPrivateRepo -> Settings -> Deploy Keys -> Add deploy key -> Paste the public key.

Now the remote server would be able to connect to the private repo.

NOTE: The deploy keys has access only for reading the repo. Need to explicitly allow write access.


J
Julian Knight

If you are using git for Windows.

Open the git GUI.

Open the local git repository in git GUI.

Add the remote or push if the remote already exists.

Answer "yes" to the question about whether you want to continue.

The GUI client adds the key for you to ~/.ssh/known_hosts. This is easier to remember if you don't do it often and also avoids the need to use the git command line (the standard Windows command lines don't have the ssh-keyscan executable.


R
RP-

The solutions mentioned here are great, the only missing point is, what if your public and private key file names are different than the default ones?

Create a file called "config" under ~/.ssh and add the following contents

Host github.com
    IdentityFile ~/.ssh/github_id_rsa

Replace github_id_rsa with your private key file.


A
Adiii

I was facing the same error inside DockerFile during build time while the image was public. I did little modification in Dockerfile.

 RUN git clone  https://github.com/kacole2/express-node-mongo-skeleton.git /www/nodejs

This would be because using the git@github.com:... syntax ends up > using SSH to clone, and inside the container, your private key is not > available. You'll want to use RUN git clone > https://github.com/edenhill/librdkafka.git instead.


E
EM0

Check permissions on the known_hosts file as well - both the user's (~/.ssh/known_hosts) and the global one (/etc/ssh/ssh_known_hosts).

In my case the old host was in /etc/ssh/ssh_known_hosts. When I removed it as root with sudo ssh-keygen -f /etc/ssh/ssh_known_hosts -R THE_HOST it changed permissions on that file to 0600, so SSHing to THE_HOST as root worked, but for any other user it failed with "Host key verification failed". The fix was:

sudo chmod 644 /etc/ssh/ssh_known_hosts

J
Jaykumar Patel

Its means your remote host key was changed (May be host password change),

Your terminal suggested to execute this command as root user

$ ssh-keygen -f "/root/.ssh/known_hosts" -R [www.website.net]

You have to remove that host name from hosts list on your pc/server. Copy that suggested command and execute as a root user.

$ sudo su                                                        // Login as a root user

$ ssh-keygen -f "/root/.ssh/known_hosts" -R [www.website.net]    // Terminal suggested command execute here
Host [www.website.net]:4231 found: line 16 type ECDSA
/root/.ssh/known_hosts updated.
Original contents retained as /root/.ssh/known_hosts.old

$ exit                                                           // Exist from root user

Try Again, Hope this works.


Note: depending on your shell, you may have to escape the square brackets \[ and \] or use quotes.
L
Lamri Djamal

You kan use https instead of ssh for git clone or git pull or git push

ex:

git clone https://github.com/user/repo.git

T
TheHowlingHoaschd

Reason seems to be that the public key of the remote host is not stored or different from the stored one. (Be aware of security issues, see Greg Bacon's answer for details.)

I was used to git clone prompting me in this case:

The authenticity of host 'host.net (10.0.0.42)' can't be established.
ECDSA key fingerprint is 00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00.
Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)?

Not sure, why this error is thrown instead. Could be the configuration of your shell or the git SSH command.
Anyhow, you can get the same prompt by running ssh user@host.net.


u
u_pendra

A other alternative worked for me, instead of cloning the SSH link

git@gitlab.company.net:upendra/mycode.git

there is a option to select http link

http://gitlab.company.net:8888/upendra/mycode.git

So I used http link to clone for Visual studio and it worked for me


T
Tk421

If you are not using a Windows Session to update the code, and you use PortableGit, you need to set the HOMEPATH environment variable before running the git command.

This example fits better for other use case, but I think it is a good of proof-of-concept for this post.

$env:HOMEPATH="\Users\Administrator";C:\path\to\PortableGit\bin\git.exe -C C:\path\to\repository.git pull'


K
K D

Pushing to Git returning Error Code 403 fatal: HTTP request failed

Check if there is Billing issue. Google Cloud stops uploading files to https://source.cloud.google.com/

I got this problem went away after Payment issue was fixed. But did not change the Keys.

Thanks


S
Stephen Ostermiller

One small addition to Tupy's answer, you may need to add the port number for your repository host:

ssh-keyscan -p 8888 -t rsa domain.example >> ~/.ssh/known_hosts

If you have another machine that does have remote access you can find the port number by viewing ~/.ssh/known_hosts:

[user]$ less ~/.ssh/known_hosts
[domain.example]:8888,[000.00.000.000]:8888 ssh-rsa AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQCi...

N
Nitin

You can use your "git url" in 'https" URL format in the Jenkinsfile or wherever you want.

git url: 'https://github.com/jglick/simple-maven-project-with-tests.git'


P
Prometheos II

Alternatively, if you're using MSYS2 terminals (on Windows*) and a passphrase, it might be that the terminal does not prompt the 'Enter passphrase' properly, thus denying access to SSH.

If you're on Windows, you can instead use the Git Bash or Powershell to get the prompt and properly connect. (I'm currently looking for a solution for MSYS.)

*Not sure if relevant.


T
TRUPAL VASAVA

Problem: Host key verification failed. fatal: Could not read from remote repository.

Please make sure you have the correct access rights and the repository exists.

Solution: I've checked all the settings and also checked the key settings in GitHub. Finally, I changed the Git URL from "git@github.com:palvsv/travelo-moon.git" to "https://github.com/palvsv/travelo-moon.git" in .config file "yourprojectdirectory/.git/config" and it works.


I also had to do this, thank you!
This worked for me!, thank you @TRUPAL
This simply changes the authentication method from SSH to HTTPS - this is not a solution if you're actually trying to use SSH keys, which the OP was not, however a bunch of other people here are, so I would say this isn't extremely valid for 90% of use cases.
l
li bo

for me, I just rename the "known_hosts" file to "known_hosts.del" for backup. and then rerun git clone xxx and type "yes". I will create new "known_hosts"


There are 26 existing answers to this question, including a top-voted, accepted answer with over five hundred votes. Are you certain your solution hasn't already been given? If not, why do you believe your approach improves upon the existing proposals, which have been validated by the community? Offering an explanation is always useful on Stack Overflow, but it's especially important where the question has been resolved to the satisfaction of both the OP and the community. Help readers out by explaining what your answer does different and when it might be preferred.
J
Jerome Vacher

I had the similar issue, unfortunately I used the GitExtensions HMI and forgot that I wrote a passphrase. With HMI.... forget it ! Do not enter passphrase when you generate your key !


f
fyodrs

I got this message when I tried to git clone a repo that was not mine. The fix was to fork and then clone.