ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

Python Pandas Error tokenizing data

I'm trying to use pandas to manipulate a .csv file but I get this error:

pandas.parser.CParserError: Error tokenizing data. C error: Expected 2 fields in line 3, saw 12

I have tried to read the pandas docs, but found nothing.

My code is simple:

path = 'GOOG Key Ratios.csv'
#print(open(path).read())
data = pd.read_csv(path)

How can I resolve this? Should I use the csv module or another language ?

File is from Morningstar

If this error arises when reading a file written by pandas.to_csv(), it MIGHT be because there is a '\r' in a column names, in which case to_csv() will actually write the subsequent column names into the first column of the data frame, causing a difference between the number of columns in the first X rows. This difference is one cause of the C error.
Sometime just explicitly giving the "sep" parameter helps. Seems to be a parser issue.
This error may arise also when you're using comma as a delimiter and you have more commas then expected (more fields in the error row then defined in the header). So you need to either remove the additional field or remove the extra comma if it's there by mistake. You can fix this manually and then you don't need to skip the error lines.
Comment from gilgamash helped me. Open csv file in a text editor (like the windows editor or notepad++) so see which character is used for separation. If it's a semicolon e.g. try pd.read_csv("<path>", sep=";"). Do not use Excel for checking as it sometimes puts the data into columns by default and therefore removes the separator.
had a similar issue. Realized it was due to my csv file having a value with a comma in it. Had to encapsulate it with " "

c
constantstranger

you could also try;

data = pd.read_csv('file1.csv', on_bad_lines='skip')

Do note that this will cause the offending lines to be skipped.

Edit

For Pandas < 1.3.0 try

data = pd.read_csv("file1.csv", error_bad_lines=False)

as per pandas API reference.


Stumbled on this answer, is there a way to fill missing columns on lines that outputs something like expected 8 fields, saw 9?
The better solution is to investigate the offending file and to correct the bad lines so that they can be read by read_csv. @PetraBarus, why not just add columns to the CSV files that are missing them (with null values as needed)?
Yes, I just did that. It's much easier by adding columns. Opening CSV in a spreadsheet does this.
Passing in names=["col1", "col2", ...] for the max number of expected columns also works, and this is how I solved this issue when I came across it. See: stackoverflow.com/questions/18039057/…
This should not be the accepted answer, lines will be skipped and you don't know why...
D
Dr Manhattan

It might be an issue with

the delimiters in your data

the first row, as @TomAugspurger noted

To solve it, try specifying the sep and/or header arguments when calling read_csv. For instance,

df = pandas.read_csv(filepath, sep='delimiter', header=None)

In the code above, sep defines your delimiter and header=None tells pandas that your source data has no row for headers / column titles. Thus saith the docs: "If file contains no header row, then you should explicitly pass header=None". In this instance, pandas automatically creates whole-number indices for each field {0,1,2,...}.

According to the docs, the delimiter thing should not be an issue. The docs say that "if sep is None [not specified], will try to automatically determine this." I however have not had good luck with this, including instances with obvious delimiters.

Another solution may be to try auto detect the delimiter

# use the first 2 lines of the file to detect separator
temp_lines = csv_file.readline() + '\n' + csv_file.readline()
dialect = csv.Sniffer().sniff(temp_lines, delimiters=';,')

# remember to go back to the start of the file for the next time it's read
csv_file.seek(0) 

df = pd.read_csv(csv_file, sep=dialect.delimiter)


T
TomAugspurger

The parser is getting confused by the header of the file. It reads the first row and infers the number of columns from that row. But the first two rows aren't representative of the actual data in the file.

Try it with data = pd.read_csv(path, skiprows=2)


L
Lucas

This is definitely an issue of delimiter, as most of the csv CSV are got create using sep='/t' so try to read_csv using the tab character (\t) using separator /t. so, try to open using following code line.

data=pd.read_csv("File_path", sep='\t')

@MichaelQueue : This is incorrect. A CSV, although commonly delimited by a comma, may be delimited by other characters as well. See CSV specifications. It may be a comma, a tab ('\t'), semicolon, and possibly additional spaces. :)
in my case it was a separator issue. read_csv apparently defaults to commas, and i have text fields which include commas (and the data was stored with a different separator anyway)
If commas are used in the values but tab is the delimiter and sep is not used (or as suggested above the delimiters whatever it is assumed to be occurs in the values) then this error will arise. Make sure that the delimiter does not occur in any of the values else some rows will appear to have the incorrect number of columns
I'm using excel 2016 while creating the CSV, and using sep=';' work for me
S
Steven Rouk

I had this problem, where I was trying to read in a CSV without passing in column names.

df = pd.read_csv(filename, header=None)

I specified the column names in a list beforehand and then pass them into names, and it solved it immediately. If you don't have set column names, you could just create as many placeholder names as the maximum number of columns that might be in your data.

col_names = ["col1", "col2", "col3", ...]
df = pd.read_csv(filename, names=col_names)

This answer better because the row doesn't get deleted compared to if using the error_bad_line=False. Additionally, you can easily figure out which lines were the problem ones once making a dataframe from this solution.
I agree with @zipline86. This answer is safe and intelligent.
this solution its too hackish to me, but it works. I solved my issue passing engine='python' in read_csv to deal with variable columns size
A
Ajean

Your CSV file might have variable number of columns and read_csv inferred the number of columns from the first few rows. Two ways to solve it in this case:

1) Change the CSV file to have a dummy first line with max number of columns (and specify header=[0])

2) Or use names = list(range(0,N)) where N is the max number of columns.


names=range(N) should suffice (using pandas=1.1.2 here)
R
Robert Geiger

I had this problem as well but perhaps for a different reason. I had some trailing commas in my CSV that were adding an additional column that pandas was attempting to read. Using the following works but it simply ignores the bad lines:

data = pd.read_csv('file1.csv', error_bad_lines=False)

If you want to keep the lines an ugly kind of hack for handling the errors is to do something like the following:

line     = []
expected = []
saw      = []     
cont     = True 

while cont == True:     
    try:
        data = pd.read_csv('file1.csv',skiprows=line)
        cont = False
    except Exception as e:    
        errortype = e.message.split('.')[0].strip()                                
        if errortype == 'Error tokenizing data':                        
           cerror      = e.message.split(':')[1].strip().replace(',','')
           nums        = [n for n in cerror.split(' ') if str.isdigit(n)]
           expected.append(int(nums[0]))
           saw.append(int(nums[2]))
           line.append(int(nums[1])-1)
         else:
           cerror      = 'Unknown'
           print 'Unknown Error - 222'

if line != []:
    # Handle the errors however you want

I proceeded to write a script to reinsert the lines into the DataFrame since the bad lines will be given by the variable 'line' in the above code. This can all be avoided by simply using the csv reader. Hopefully the pandas developers can make it easier to deal with this situation in the future.


Thank you for this solution !! It's a very useful tip.
d
d_-

The following worked for me (I posted this answer, because I specifically had this problem in a Google Colaboratory Notebook):

df = pd.read_csv("/path/foo.csv", delimiter=';', skiprows=0, low_memory=False)

I experimented problems when not setting | as the delimiter for my .csv. I rather to try this approach first, instead of skipping lines, or bad lines.
I also had the same problem, I assumed "\t" would be detected as a delimiter by default. It worked when I explicitly set the delimiter to "\t".
I had the same problem for a large .csv file (~250MB), with some corrupted lines spanning less columns than the data frame actually has. I was able to avoid the exception in two ways: 1) By modifying (for example deleting) a couple of unrelated rows far away from the line causing the exception. 2) By setting low_memory=False. In other .csv files with the same type of mal-formatted lines, I don't observe any problems. In summary, this indicates that the handling of large-file by pandas.read_csv() somehow is flawed.
I filed a bug report related to my previous comment.
d
double-beep

You can try;

data = pd.read_csv('file1.csv', sep='\t')

While this code may solve the question, including an explanation of how and why this solves the problem would really help to improve the quality of your post, and probably result in more up-votes. Remember that you are answering the question for readers in the future, not just the person asking now. Please edit your answer to add explanations and give an indication of what limitations and assumptions apply. From Review
e
elPastor

I've had this problem a few times myself. Almost every time, the reason is that the file I was attempting to open was not a properly saved CSV to begin with. And by "properly", I mean each row had the same number of separators or columns.

Typically it happened because I had opened the CSV in Excel then improperly saved it. Even though the file extension was still .csv, the pure CSV format had been altered.

Any file saved with pandas to_csv will be properly formatted and shouldn't have that issue. But if you open it with another program, it may change the structure.

Hope that helps.


L
Legend_Ari

I came across the same issue. Using pd.read_table() on the same source file seemed to work. I could not trace the reason for this but it was a useful workaround for my case. Perhaps someone more knowledgeable can shed more light on why it worked.

Edit: I found that this error creeps up when you have some text in your file that does not have the same format as the actual data. This is usually header or footer information (greater than one line, so skip_header doesn't work) which will not be separated by the same number of commas as your actual data (when using read_csv). Using read_table uses a tab as the delimiter which could circumvent the users current error but introduce others.

I usually get around this by reading the extra data into a file then use the read_csv() method.

The exact solution might differ depending on your actual file, but this approach has worked for me in several cases


l
lotrus28

I've had a similar problem while trying to read a tab-delimited table with spaces, commas and quotes:

1115794 4218    "k__Bacteria", "p__Firmicutes", "c__Bacilli", "o__Bacillales", "f__Bacillaceae", ""
1144102 3180    "k__Bacteria", "p__Firmicutes", "c__Bacilli", "o__Bacillales", "f__Bacillaceae", "g__Bacillus", ""
368444  2328    "k__Bacteria", "p__Bacteroidetes", "c__Bacteroidia", "o__Bacteroidales", "f__Bacteroidaceae", "g__Bacteroides", ""



import pandas as pd
# Same error for read_table
counts = pd.read_csv(path_counts, sep='\t', index_col=2, header=None, engine = 'c')

pandas.io.common.CParserError: Error tokenizing data. C error: out of memory

This says it has something to do with C parsing engine (which is the default one). Maybe changing to a python one will change anything

counts = pd.read_table(path_counts, sep='\t', index_col=2, header=None, engine='python')

Segmentation fault (core dumped)

Now that is a different error. If we go ahead and try to remove spaces from the table, the error from python-engine changes once again:

1115794 4218    "k__Bacteria","p__Firmicutes","c__Bacilli","o__Bacillales","f__Bacillaceae",""
1144102 3180    "k__Bacteria","p__Firmicutes","c__Bacilli","o__Bacillales","f__Bacillaceae","g__Bacillus",""
368444  2328    "k__Bacteria","p__Bacteroidetes","c__Bacteroidia","o__Bacteroidales","f__Bacteroidaceae","g__Bacteroides",""


_csv.Error: '   ' expected after '"'

And it gets clear that pandas was having problems parsing our rows. To parse a table with python engine I needed to remove all spaces and quotes from the table beforehand. Meanwhile C-engine kept crashing even with commas in rows. To avoid creating a new file with replacements I did this, as my tables are small:

from io import StringIO
with open(path_counts) as f:
    input = StringIO(f.read().replace('", ""', '').replace('"', '').replace(', ', ',').replace('\0',''))
    counts = pd.read_table(input, sep='\t', index_col=2, header=None, engine='python')

tl;dr Change parsing engine, try to avoid any non-delimiting quotes/commas/spaces in your data.


B
Bhavesh Kumar

Use delimiter in parameter

pd.read_csv(filename, delimiter=",", encoding='utf-8')

It will read.


佚名

The dataset that I used had a lot of quote marks (") used extraneous of the formatting. I was able to fix the error by including this parameter for read_csv():

quoting=3 # 3 correlates to csv.QUOTE_NONE for pandas

stumbled across the exact same thing. As far as I'm concerned, this is the correct answer. The accepted one just hides the error.
Correct answer for me too. +1
d
double-beep

For those who are having similar issue with Python 3 on linux OS.

pandas.errors.ParserError: Error tokenizing data. C error: Calling
read(nbytes) on source failed. Try engine='python'.

Try:

df.read_csv('file.csv', encoding='utf8', engine='python')

I had a file where there were commas in some certain fields/columns and while trying to read through pandas read_csv() it was failing, but after specifying engine="python" within read_csv() as a parameter it worked - Thanks for this!
K
Kareem Jeiroudi

As far as I can tell, and after taking a look at your file, the problem is that the csv file you're trying to load has multiple tables. There are empty lines, or lines that contain table titles. Try to have a look at this Stackoverflow answer. It shows how to achieve that programmatically.

Another dynamic approach to do that would be to use the csv module, read every single row at a time and make sanity checks/regular expressions, to infer if the row is (title/header/values/blank). You have one more advantage with this approach, that you can split/append/collect your data in python objects as desired.

The easiest of all would be to use pandas function pd.read_clipboard() after manually selecting and copying the table to the clipboard, in case you can open the csv in excel or something.

Irrelevant:

Additionally, irrelevant to your problem, but because no one made mention of this: I had this same issue when loading some datasets such as seeds_dataset.txt from UCI. In my case, the error was occurring because some separators had more whitespaces than a true tab \t. See line 3 in the following for instance

14.38   14.21   0.8951  5.386   3.312   2.462   4.956   1
14.69   14.49   0.8799  5.563   3.259   3.586   5.219   1
14.11   14.1    0.8911  5.42    3.302   2.7     5       1

Therefore, use \t+ in the separator pattern instead of \t.

data = pd.read_csv(path, sep='\t+`, header=None)

Thanks, delimiter="\t+" solved the error for me!
R
RegularlyScheduledProgramming

Although not the case for this question, this error may also appear with compressed data. Explicitly setting the value for kwarg compression resolved my problem.

result = pandas.read_csv(data_source, compression='gzip')

M
Mihai.Mehe

In my case the separator was not the default "," but Tab.

pd.read_csv(file_name.csv, sep='\\t',lineterminator='\\r', engine='python', header='infer')

Note: "\t" did not work as suggested by some sources. "\\t" was required.


L
Laurent T

I believe the solutions,

,engine='python'
, error_bad_lines = False

will be good if it is dummy columns and you want to delete it. In my case, the second row really had more columns and I wanted those columns to be integrated and to have the number of columns = MAX(columns).

Please refer to the solution below that I could not read anywhere:

try:
    df_data = pd.read_csv(PATH, header = bl_header, sep = str_sep)
except pd.errors.ParserError as err:
    str_find = 'saw '
    int_position = int(str(err).find(str_find)) + len(str_find)
    str_nbCol = str(err)[int_position:]
    l_col = range(int(str_nbCol))
    df_data = pd.read_csv(PATH, header = bl_header, sep = str_sep, names = l_col)

I will take any better way to find the number of columns in the error message than what i just did
This answer really need more upvotes. Thank you very muc.
S
Sachin

I came across multiple solutions for this issue. Lot's of folks have given the best explanation for the answers also. But for the beginners I think below two methods will be enough :

import pandas as pd

#Method 1

data = pd.read_csv('file1.csv', error_bad_lines=False)
#Note that this will cause the offending lines to be skipped.

#Method 2 using sep

data = pd.read_csv('file1.csv', sep='\t')

A
Aks4125

Sometimes the problem is not how to use python, but with the raw data. I got this error message

Error tokenizing data. C error: Expected 18 fields in line 72, saw 19.

It turned out that in the column description there were sometimes commas. This means that the CSV file needs to be cleaned up or another separator used.


b
bcoz

An alternative that I have found to be useful in dealing with similar parsing errors uses the CSV module to re-route data into a pandas df. For example:

import csv
import pandas as pd
path = 'C:/FileLocation/'
file = 'filename.csv'
f = open(path+file,'rt')
reader = csv.reader(f)

#once contents are available, I then put them in a list
csv_list = []
for l in reader:
    csv_list.append(l)
f.close()
#now pandas has no problem getting into a df
df = pd.DataFrame(csv_list)

I find the CSV module to be a bit more robust to poorly formatted comma separated files and so have had success with this route to address issues like these.


k
kepy97

following sequence of commands works (I lose the first line of the data -no header=None present-, but at least it loads):

df = pd.read_csv(filename, usecols=range(0, 42)) df.columns = ['YR', 'MO', 'DAY', 'HR', 'MIN', 'SEC', 'HUND', 'ERROR', 'RECTYPE', 'LANE', 'SPEED', 'CLASS', 'LENGTH', 'GVW', 'ESAL', 'W1', 'S1', 'W2', 'S2', 'W3', 'S3', 'W4', 'S4', 'W5', 'S5', 'W6', 'S6', 'W7', 'S7', 'W8', 'S8', 'W9', 'S9', 'W10', 'S10', 'W11', 'S11', 'W12', 'S12', 'W13', 'S13', 'W14']

Following does NOT work:

df = pd.read_csv(filename, names=['YR', 'MO', 'DAY', 'HR', 'MIN', 'SEC', 'HUND', 'ERROR', 'RECTYPE', 'LANE', 'SPEED', 'CLASS', 'LENGTH', 'GVW', 'ESAL', 'W1', 'S1', 'W2', 'S2', 'W3', 'S3', 'W4', 'S4', 'W5', 'S5', 'W6', 'S6', 'W7', 'S7', 'W8', 'S8', 'W9', 'S9', 'W10', 'S10', 'W11', 'S11', 'W12', 'S12', 'W13', 'S13', 'W14'], usecols=range(0, 42))

CParserError: Error tokenizing data. C error: Expected 53 fields in line 1605634, saw 54 Following does NOT work:

df = pd.read_csv(filename, header=None)

CParserError: Error tokenizing data. C error: Expected 53 fields in line 1605634, saw 54

Hence, in your problem you have to pass usecols=range(0, 2)


A
Abhishek Tripathi

use pandas.read_csv('CSVFILENAME',header=None,sep=', ')

when trying to read csv data from the link

http://archive.ics.uci.edu/ml/machine-learning-databases/adult/adult.data

I copied the data from the site into my csvfile. It had extra spaces so used sep =', ' and it worked :)


A
Adewole Adesola

I had a similar case as this and setting

train = pd.read_csv('input.csv' , encoding='latin1',engine='python') 

worked


N
Naseer

Simple resolution: Open the csv file in excel & save it with different name file of csv format. Again try importing it spyder, Your problem will be resolved!


Dude! Thank you. Your solution worked like a light switch.
a
amran hossen

Error tokenizing data. C error: Expected 2 fields in line 3, saw 12

The error gives a clue to solve the problem " Expected 2 fields in line 3, saw 12", saw 12 means length of the second row is 12 and first row is 2.

When you have data like the one shown below, if you skip rows then most of the data will be skipped

data = """1,2,3
1,2,3,4
1,2,3,4,5
1,2
1,2,3,4"""

If you dont want to skip any rows do the following

#First lets find the maximum column for all the rows
with open("file_name.csv", 'r') as temp_f:
    # get No of columns in each line
    col_count = [ len(l.split(",")) for l in temp_f.readlines() ]

### Generate column names  (names will be 0, 1, 2, ..., maximum columns - 1)
column_names = [i for i in range(max(col_count))] 

import pandas as pd
# inside range set the maximum value you can see in "Expected 4 fields in line 2, saw 8"
# here will be 8 
data = pd.read_csv("file_name.csv",header = None,names=column_names )

Use range instead of manually setting names as it will be cumbersome when you have many columns.

Additionally you can fill up the NaN values with 0, if you need to use even data length. Eg. for clustering (k-means)

new_data = data.fillna(0)

g
gogasca

I had a dataset with prexisting row numbers, I used index_col:

pd.read_csv('train.csv', index_col=0)

s
ssuperczynski

This is what I did.

sep='::' solved my issue:

data=pd.read_csv('C:\\Users\\HP\\Downloads\\NPL ASSINGMENT 2 imdb_labelled\\imdb_labelled.txt',engine='python',header=None,sep='::')

S
Simin Zuo

I have the same problem when read_csv: ParserError: Error tokenizing data. I just saved the old csv file to a new csv file. The problem is solved!