ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

How can I temporarily disable a foreign key constraint in MySQL?

Is it possible to temporarily disable constraints in MySQL?

I have two Django models, each with a foreign key to the other one. Deleting instances of a model returns an error because of the foreign key constraint:

cursor.execute("DELETE FROM myapp_item WHERE n = %s", n)
transaction.commit_unless_managed()  #a foreign key constraint fails here

cursor.execute("DELETE FROM myapp_style WHERE n = %s", n)
transaction.commit_unless_managed()

Is it possible to temporarily disable constraints and delete anyway?

Either I don't get what you want to do, or what you are trying to do is very, very, very ugly. Even if you can do it, you probably shouldn't.
Dropping and reapplying an FK is changing your db. You're trying to defy the very constraints that allow the system to see some sense, it has no regard that an FK could be a temporary thing, and if it did know, it would panic.
Its strange what you trying to do. But which database are you using?
what if, instead of disabling your constraint, you permanently modified it to ON DELETE SET NULL? That would accomplish a similar thing and you wouldn't have to turn key checking on and off.
@dnagirl: that would be better, indeed. How can I do that?

P
Peter Mortensen

Try DISABLE KEYS or

SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=0;

Make sure to

SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=1;

after.


is this something that is set for mysql as a whole or just that session?
I believe it is per session.
Can I just disable FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS for a single table?
To clarify @Pacerier's comment: For Innodb, you cannot DISABLE KEYS. But you can accomplish what is requested in this question, using the other command shown: SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=0; (I thought at first he was saying there was no way to accomplish this.)
b
berniey

To turn off foreign key constraint globally, do the following:

SET GLOBAL FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=0;

and remember to set it back when you are done

SET GLOBAL FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=1;

WARNING: You should only do this when you are doing single user mode maintenance. As it might resulted in data inconsistency. For example, it will be very helpful when you are uploading large amount of data using a mysqldump output.


this is what I needed to know, so its not great practice, but this guys answer should be scoring higher...
This worked for me after trying the 'best answer' didn't work for me. Perhaps an explanation of the difference could be added.
@hexnet The difference is that just SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS just changes the value for the current connection, while SET GLOBAL .. changes the value for all connections, including future connections. If you just do SET FOREIGN.. in one window, then try to apply the statement in a different window (over a different connection), the value has not changed there. With GLOBAL, the same variable has the same value for both connections.
The only thing that could help me when playing back a larger dump (6+ GB) <3
This doesn't work for me. When I try, I see:ERROR 1228 (HY000): Variable 'foreign_key_checks' is a SESSION variable and can't be used with SET GLOBAL
A
AntonioCS

I normally only disable foreign key constraints when I want to truncate a table, and since I keep coming back to this answer this is for future me:

SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=0;
TRUNCATE TABLE table;
SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=1;

d
dnagirl

Instead of disabling your constraint, permanently modify it to ON DELETE SET NULL. That will accomplish a similar thing and you wouldn't have to turn key checking on and off. Like so:

ALTER TABLE tablename1 DROP FOREIGN KEY fk_name1; //get rid of current constraints
ALTER TABLE tablename2 DROP FOREIGN KEY fk_name2;

ALTER TABLE tablename1 
  ADD FOREIGN KEY (table2_id) 
        REFERENCES table2(id)
        ON DELETE SET NULL  //add back constraint

ALTER TABLE tablename2 
  ADD FOREIGN KEY (table1_id) 
        REFERENCES table1(id)
        ON DELETE SET NULL //add back other constraint

Have a read of this (http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.5/en/alter-table.html) and this (http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.5/en/create-table-foreign-keys.html).


Beware alterting table can take a long time, better to set the server global for FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS to 0 and put it back once the dirty work is done. Besides it might lock for writing your tables.
Won't that break the reference when altering the remote column type? (It seems my client renames a modified temp table to the original table name.)
P
Peter Mortensen

To turn off the foreign key constraint globally:

SET GLOBAL FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS = 0;

And for the active foreign key constraint:

SET GLOBAL FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS = 1;

P
Peter Mortensen

A very simple solution with phpMyAdmin:

In your table, go to the SQL tab

After you edit the SQL command that you want to run, there is a check box next to GO, named 'Enable foreign key checks' .

Uncheck this check box and run your SQL. It will be automatically rechecked after executing.


Thanks! Indeed solution SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=0; ..... SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=1; didn't work for me in PHPMyAdmin because I forgot to uncheck the 'Enable foreign key checks' checkbox. In PHPMyAdmin you can skip these SET commands and just uncheck the checkbox.
R
RotS

For me just SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=0; wasn't enough. I was still having a com.mysql.jdbc.exceptions.jdbc4.MySQLIntegrityConstraintViolationException.

I had to add ALTER TABLE myTable DISABLE KEYS;.

So:

SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=0;
ALTER TABLE myTable DISABLE KEYS;
DELETE FROM myTable;
ALTER TABLE myTable ENABLE KEYS;
SET FOREIGN_KEY_CHECKS=1;

FYI, mySQL 5.7 throws warning, InnoDB engine doesn't have this option when running DISABLE KEYS command.
this did work, without the alter table it also didn't work for me
C
Chanoch

If the key field is nullable, then you can also set the value to null before attempting to delete it:

cursor.execute("UPDATE myapp_item SET myapp_style_id = NULL WHERE n = %s", n)
transaction.commit_unless_managed() 

cursor.execute("UPDATE myapp_style SET myapp_item_id = NULL WHERE n = %s", n)
transaction.commit_unless_managed()

cursor.execute("DELETE FROM myapp_item WHERE n = %s", n)
transaction.commit_unless_managed()

cursor.execute("DELETE FROM myapp_style WHERE n = %s", n)
transaction.commit_unless_managed()

J
Julian

In phpMyAdmin you can select multiple rows and can then click the delete action. You'll enter a screen which lists the delete queries. It looks like this:

https://i.stack.imgur.com/Y8Xgv.png

Please uncheck the "Enable foreign key checks" checkbox, and click on Yes to execute them.

This will enable you to delete rows even if there is an ON DELETE restriction constraint.


P
Pang

It's not a good idea to set a foreign key constraint to 0, because if you do, your database would not ensure it is not violating referential integrity. This could lead to inaccurate, misleading, or incomplete data.

You make a foreign key for a reason: because all the values in the child column shall be the same as a value in the parent column. If there are no foreign key constraints, a child row can have a value that is not in the parent row, which would lead to inaccurate data.

For instance, let's say you have a website for students to login and every student must register for an account as a user. You have one table for user ids, with user id as a primary key; and another table for student accounts, with student id as a column. Since every student must have a user id, it would make sense to make the student id from the student accounts table a foreign key that references the primary key user id in the user ids table. If there are no foreign key checks, a student could end up having a student id and no user id, which means a student can get an account without being a user, which is wrong.

Imagine if it happens to a large amount of data. That's why you need the foreign key check.

It's best to figure out what is causing the error. Most likely, you are trying to delete from a parent row without deleting from a child row. Try deleting from the child row before deleting from the parent row.


True, there's always a trade-off.
No one is saying to run it like this forever. You turn off constraints, bulk load some data, and flip it back on. No big deal, people do it all the time.
it is necessary for bulk imports, for performance at least, it is very common. also sometimes you just need the data to be restored, then you can make your checks.
This is not an answer to the question.
Note, his question is how to do this temporarily. This is required when doing certain maintenance and data imports. The caveat of course is that your import scripts become responsible for data integrity. Then, later when the indexes and constraints are turned back on, the db will tell you if something is broken.