ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

What's the scope of a variable initialized in an if statement?

I'm new to Python, so this is probably a simple scoping question. The following code in a Python file (module) is confusing me slightly:

if __name__ == '__main__':
    x = 1

print x

In other languages I've worked in, this code would throw an exception, as the x variable is local to the if statement and should not exist outside of it. But this code executes, and prints 1. Can anyone explain this behavior? Are all variables created in a module global/available to the entire module?

Another quirk you might not be aware of: if the if statement above does not hold true (i.e., __name__ is not '__main__', for example when you import the module instead of executing it top-level), then x will never have been bound, and the subsequent print x statement will throw a NameError: name 'x' is not defined.

u
user2357112

Python variables are scoped to the innermost function, class, or module in which they're assigned. Control blocks like if and while blocks don't count, so a variable assigned inside an if is still scoped to a function, class, or module.

(Implicit functions defined by a generator expression or list/set/dict comprehension do count, as do lambda expressions. You can't stuff an assignment statement into any of those, but lambda parameters and for clause targets are implicit assignment.)


Thanks for this answer. I've been coding in python for years now and didn't understand this until now. Knowing this does makes things easier. I always found the way python handle scopes to be of a con sometimes.
n
nbro

Yes, they're in the same "local scope", and actually code like this is common in Python:

if condition:
  x = 'something'
else:
  x = 'something else'

use(x)

Note that x isn't declared or initialized before the condition, like it would be in C or Java, for example.

In other words, Python does not have block-level scopes. Be careful, though, with examples such as

if False:
    x = 3
print(x)

which would clearly raise a NameError exception.


I fell in the if False: trap.
D
Daniel G

Scope in python follows this order:

Search the local scope

Search the scope of any enclosing functions

Search the global scope

Search the built-ins

(source)

Notice that if and other looping/branching constructs are not listed - only classes, functions, and modules provide scope in Python, so anything declared in an if block has the same scope as anything decleared outside the block. Variables aren't checked at compile time, which is why other languages throw an exception. In python, so long as the variable exists at the time you require it, no exception will be thrown.


S
Skilldrick

As Eli said, Python doesn't require variable declaration. In C you would say:

int x;
if(something)
    x = 1;
else
    x = 2;

but in Python declaration is implicit, so when you assign to x it is automatically declared. It's because Python is dynamically typed - it wouldn't work in a statically typed language, because depending on the path used, a variable might be used without being declared. This would be caught at compile time in a statically typed language, but with a dynamically typed language it's allowed.

The only reason that a statically typed language is limited to having to declare variables outside of if statements in because of this problem. Embrace the dynamic!


P
Paul Stephenson

Unlike languages such as C, a Python variable is in scope for the whole of the function (or class, or module) where it appears, not just in the innermost "block". It is as though you declared int x at the top of the function (or class, or module), except that in Python you don't have to declare variables.

Note that the existence of the variable x is checked only at runtime -- that is, when you get to the print x statement. If __name__ didn't equal "__main__" then you would get an exception: NameError: name 'x' is not defined.


Classes do not create a scope; a "local" variable in a class is simply added to the class's dict upon creation.
O
Olivier Verdier

Yes. It is also true for for scope. But not functions of course.

In your example: if the condition in the if statement is false, x will not be defined though.


S
SilentGhost

you're executing this code from command line therefore if conditions is true and x is set. Compare:

>>> if False:
    y = 42


>>> y
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "<pyshell#6>", line 1, in <module>
    y
NameError: name 'y' is not defined