ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

position: fixed doesn't work on iPad and iPhone

I have been struggling with fixed positioning in iPad for a while. I know iScroll and it does not always seem to work (even in their demo). I also know that Sencha has a fix for that, but I couldn't Ctrl + F the source code for that fix.

I am hoping that someone may have the solution. The problem is that fixed positioned elements do not get updated when the user pans down/up on an iOS powered mobile Safari.

Looks like jQuery Mobile 1.1 solved this problem: jquerymobile.com/blog/2012/04/13/announcing-jquery-mobile-1-1-0
possible duplicate of Fixed positioning in Mobile Safari
Possible duplicate of several SO questions. See gist.github.com/avesus/… for details.

G
GNTC

A lot of mobile browsers deliberately do not support position:fixed; on the grounds that fixed elements could get in the way on a small screen.

The Quirksmode.org site has a very good blog post that explains the problem: http://www.quirksmode.org/blog/archives/2010/12/the_fifth_posit.html

Also see this page for a compatibility chart showing which mobile browsers support position:fixed;: http://www.quirksmode.org/m/css.html

(but note that the mobile browser world is moving very quickly, so tables like this may not stay up-to-date for long!)

Update: iOS 5 and Android 4 are both reported to have position:fixed support now.

I tested iOS 5 myself in an Apple store today and can confirm that it does work with position fixed. There are issues with zooming in and panning around a fixed element though.

I found this compatibility table far more up to date and useful than the quirksmode one: http://caniuse.com/#search=fixed

It has up to date info on Android, Opera (mini and mobile) & iOS.


position:device-fixed would be kind of redundant. position:fixed should just work to W3C specifications.
@TalviWatia - the device-fixed solution was not part of my answer. It may or may not have merit as a suggestion, but the reason for the link was the explanation of the issue rather than his suggested solution. In any case, things have moved on a lot since this answer was posted (as I said it would), and a lot of newer devices do support fixed. You still need to deal with older devices that don't, though.
So I am curious, what exactly is your solution to the problem at hand? The links you supplied while possibly helpful do not solve the problem at hand. Not to be jaded, but people tend to upvote answers that are not actually answers here on SO.
@TalviWatia: At the time I wrote the answer, there wasn't really a good solution to the question. The link I gave was the best discussion I knew of to explain why things were the way they were, which in the absence of a solution was as good as I could offer. Things have changed in the intervening period, so the discussion in the link is no longer relevant, and there are solutions now, but that's how it was at the time.
Actually position:fixed works for scale 1 but when the user zooms the ipad it won't works ok. position:device-fixed exist?? Is valid css attribute for safari ios?
J
Jonathan.

Fixed positioning doesn't work on iOS like it does on computers.

Imagine you have a sheet of paper (the webpage) under a magnifying glass(the viewport), if you move the magnifying glass and your eye, you see a different part of the page. This is how iOS works.

Now there is a sheet of clear plastic with a word on it, this sheet of plastic stays stationary no matter what (the position:fixed elements). So when you move the magnifying glass the fixed element appears to move.

Alternatively, instead of moving the magnifying glass, you move the paper (the webpage), keeping the sheet of plastic and magnifying glass still. In this case the word on the sheet of plastic will appear to stay fixed, and the rest of the content will appear to move (because it actually is) This is a traditional desktop browser.

So in iOS the viewport moves, in a traditional browser the webpage moves. In both cases the fixed elements stay still in reality; although on iOS the fixed elements appear to move.

The way to get around this, is to follow the last few paragraphs in this article

(basically disable scrolling altogether, have the content in a separate scrollable div (see the blue box at the top of the linked article), and the fixed element positioned absolutely)

"position:fixed" now works as you'd expect in iOS5.


There are some odd things that happen with position:fixed when you zoom in on IOS. See stackoverflow.com/questions/52085998/…
J
Jason D.

position: fixed does work on android/iphone for vertical scrolling. But you need to make sure your meta tags are fully set. e.g

<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, height=device-height, initial-scale=1.0, user-scalable=0, minimum-scale=1.0, maximum-scale=1.0">

Also if you're planning on having the same page work on android pre 4.0, you need to set the top position also, or a small margin will be added for some reason.


This actually worked for me. Before, position:fixed on a hidden input element (see pure css off screen navigation) caused the browser to crash on iphone ios 8.3 but not on tablet. After it works fine.
Did not work on iPad iOS 10.3, horizontal in Square stand. Granted author says this approach is for "phones".
Disabling user to zoom with user-scalable=0, minimum-scale=1.0, maximum-scale=1.0 can make the page less accessible for many users. It would be useful to add a warning about it in your answer
Thanks, worked for me on an iPad Pro 12.9
k
kenecaswell

I had this problem on Safari (iOS 10.3.3) - the browser was not redrawing until the touchend event fired. Fixed elements did not appear or were cut off.

The trick for me was adding transform: translate3d(0,0,0); to my fixed position element.

.fixed-position-on-mobile {
  position: fixed;
  transform: translate3d(0,0,0);
}

EDIT - I now know why the transform fixes the issue: hardware-acceleration. Adding the 3D transformation triggers the GPU acceleration making for a smooth transition. For more on hardware-acceleration checkout this article: http://blog.teamtreehouse.com/increase-your-sites-performance-with-hardware-accelerated-css.


This actually fixed my scrolling issue, it was bouncing on iOS devices when using fixed, added the transform and this was fixed.
U
Uğur Özpınar

now apple support that

overflow:hidden;
-webkit-overflow-scrolling:touch;

This is exactly what I was after to solve my background-size: cover and fixed issue on the iPad
This works on Mobile Safari in iOS 7. Note: It will not work for users that have not upgraded to this version yet.
Then there must be some other variables at work. I've tested on iOS 6 and it was not working, then on iOS 7 and it was.
@NeilMonroe hmm maybe. im sure i've done it on iOS 6 without prob but maybe i used an other variable. dont remember
this was really helpful, but it seems, overflow has to be set to scroll
N
Nimantha

Fixed Footer (here with jQuery):

if (navigator.platform == 'iPad' || navigator.platform == 'iPhone' || navigator.platform == 'iPod' || navigator.platform == 'Linux armv6l') 
{
    window.ontouchstart = function () 
    {
        $("#fixedDiv").css("display", "none");
    }

    window.onscroll = function() 
    { 
        var iPadPosition = window.innerHeight + window.pageYOffset-45; // 45 is the height of the Footer
         $("#fixedDiv").css("position", "absolute");
         $("#fixedDiv").css("top", iPadPosition);
         $("#fixedDiv").css("display", "block");
    }
}

// in the CSS file should stand:
#fixedDiv {position: fixed; bottom: 0; height: 45px;  whatever else}

B
Becario Senior

Avoid on the same box using transform:--- and position:fixed. Element will stay in position:static if there is any transform.


T
Tower

I ended up using the new jQuery Mobile v1.1: http://jquerymobile.com/blog/2012/04/13/announcing-jquery-mobile-1-1-0/

We now have a solid re-write that provides true fixed toolbars on the a lot of popular platforms and safely falls back to static toolbar positioning in other browsers. The coolest part about this approach is that, unlike JS-based solutions that impose the unnatural scrolling physics across all platforms, our scrolling feels 100% native because it is. This means that scrolling feels right everywhere and works with touch, mousewheel and keyboard user input. As a bonus, our CSS-based solution is super lightweight and doesn’t impact compatibility or accessibility.


Also pretty elegant (but definitely a workaround) is this method for allowing fixed objects on iOS without using jQuery or JavaScript (only uses CSS). It's pretty universally applicable. If you wanted a "floating" position:fixed element to appear in front of your scrolling page, you'd just need to give it a higher z-index value so that it stays in front.
this definitely doesn't answer the question.
N
Nimantha

The simple way to fix this problem just types transform property for your element. and it will be fixed. .classname{ position: fixed; transform: translate3d(0,0,0); }

Also you can try his way as well this is also work fine.

.classname{
      position: -webkit-sticky;
    }

a
abdullah

using jquery i am able to come up with this. it doesnt scroll smooth, but it does the trick. you can scroll down, and the fixed div pops up on top.

THE CSS

<style type="text/css">
    .btn_cardDetailsPg {height:5px !important;margin-top:-20px;}
    html, body {overflow-x:hidden;overflow-y:auto;}
    #lockDiv {
  background-color: #fff;
  color: #000;
  float:left;
  -moz-box-shadow: 0px 4px 2px 2px #ccc;-webkit-box-shadow: 0px 4px 2px 2px #ccc;box-shadow:0px 4px 2px 2px #ccc;
  }
#lockDiv.stick {
  position: fixed;
  top: 0;
  z-index: 10000;
  margin-left:0px;
  }
</style>

THE HTML

<div id="lockSticky"></div>
<div id="lockDiv">fooo</div>

THE jQUERY

<script type="text/javascript">
    function sticky_relocate() {
        var window_top = $(window).scrollTop();
        var div_top = $('#lockSticky').offset().top;
        if (window_top > div_top)
            $('#lockDiv').addClass('stick')
        else
            $('#lockDiv').removeClass('stick');
    }
    $(function() {
        $(window).scroll(sticky_relocate);
        sticky_relocate();
    });
</script>

Finally we want to determine if the ipod touch in landscape or portrait mode to display accordingly

<script type="text/javascript">
    if (navigator.userAgent.match(/like Mac OS X/i)) {
        window.onscroll = function() {

        if (window.innerWidth > window.innerHeight) {
            //alert("landscape [ ]");
            document.getElementById('lockDiv').style.top =
            (window.pageYOffset + window.innerHeight - 268) + 'px';
        }

        if (window.innerHeight > window.innerWidth) {
            //alert("portrait ||");
            document.getElementById('lockDiv').style.top =
            (window.pageYOffset + window.innerHeight - 418) + 'px';
        }
        };
    }
</script>

T
Talvi Watia

Even though the CSS attribute {position:fixed;} seems (mostly) working on newer iOS devices, it is possible to have the device quirk and fallback to {position:relative;} on occasion and without cause or reason. Usually clearing the cache will help, until something happens and the quirk happens again.

Specifically, from Apple itself Preparing Your Web Content for iPad:

Safari on iPad and Safari on iPhone do not have resizable windows. In Safari on iPhone and iPad, the window size is set to the size of the screen (minus Safari user interface controls), and cannot be changed by the user. To move around a webpage, the user changes the zoom level and position of the viewport as they double tap or pinch to zoom in or out, or by touching and dragging to pan the page. As a user changes the zoom level and position of the viewport they are doing so within a viewable content area of fixed size (that is, the window). This means that webpage elements that have their position "fixed" to the viewport can end up outside the viewable content area, offscreen.

What is ironic, Android devices do not seem to have this issue. Also it is entirely possible to use {position:absolute;} when in reference to the body tag and not have any issues.

I found the root cause of this quirk; that it is the scroll event not playing nice when used in conjunction with the HTML or BODY tag. Sometimes it does not like to fire the event, or you will have to wait until the scroll swing event is finished to receive the event. Specifically, the viewport is re-drawn at the end of this event and fixed elements can be re-positioned somewhere else in the viewport.

So this is what I do: (avoid using the viewport, and stick with the DOM!)

<html>
  <style>
    .fixed{
      position:fixed;
      /*you can set your other static attributes here too*/
      /*like height and width, margin, etc.*/
      }
    .scrollableDiv{
      position:relative;
      overflow-y:scroll;
      /*all children will scroll within this like the body normally would.*/
      } 
    .viewportSizedBody{
      position:relative;
      overflow:hidden;
      /*this will prevent the body page itself from scrolling.*/
      } 
  </style>
  <body class="viewportSizedBody">
    <div id="myFixedContainer" class="fixed">
       This part is fixed.
    </div>
    <div id="myScrollableBody" class="scrollableDiv">
       This part is scrollable.
    </div>
  </body>
  <script type="text/javascript" src="{your path to jquery}/jquery-1.7.2.min.js"></script>
  <script>
    var theViewportHeight=$(window).height();
    $('.viewportSizedBody').css('height',theViewportHeight);
    $('#myScrollableBody').css('height',theViewportHeight);
  </script>
</html>

In essence this will cause the BODY to be the size of the viewport and non-scrollable. The scrollable DIV nested inside will scroll as the BODY normally would (minus the swing effect, so the scrolling does stop on touchend.) The fixed DIV stays fixed without interference.

As a side note, a high z-index value on the fixed DIV is important to keep the scrollable DIV appear to be behind it. I normally add in window resize and scroll events also for cross-browser and alternate screen resolution compatibility.

If all else fails, the above code will also work with both the fixed and scrollable DIVs set to {position:absolute;}.


p
phil294

This might not be applicable to all scenarios, but I found that the position: sticky (same thing with position: fixed) only works on old iPhones when the scrolling container is not the body, but inside something else.

Example pseudo html:

body                         <- scrollbar
   relative div
       sticky div

The sticky div will be sticky on desktop browsers, but with certain devices, tested with: Chromium: dev tools: device emultation: iPhone 6/7/8, and with Android 4 Firefox, it will not.

What will work, however, is

body
    div overflow=auto       <- scrollbar
        relative div
            sticky div

n
nnimis

In my case, it was because the fixed element was being shown by using an animation. As stated in this link:

in Safari 9.1, having a position:fixed-element inside an animated element, may cause the position:fixed-element to not appear.


m
mpalencia

Had the same issue on Iphone X. To fixed it I just add height to the container

top: 0;
height: 200px;
position: fixed;

I just added top:0 because i need my div to stay at top


v
vr_driver

This seems to work for Ionic5 on iphone 6 Plus on iOS 12.4.2

.large_player {
    float: left;
      bottom: 0;
      width: 100%;
      position: fixed;
      background-color: white;
      border-top: black 1px solid;    
      height: 14rem;
      z-index: 100;
      transform: translate3d(0,0,0);
  }

The transform tag makes it work, but it also seems a little clunky in how the scroll works, it is seems to redraw the 'on top' element after it's all moved and sort of resets and makes it jump a little.

Or, you could also use this tag option as well, position: -webkit-sticky;, but then you won't get, or may run in to trouble with WPA/browser or Android builds while having to do version checking and have multiple CSS tags.

.large_player {
    float: left;
      bottom: 0;
      width: 100%;
      position: -webkit-sticky;
      background-color: white;
      border-top: black 1px solid;    
      height: 14rem;
      z-index: 100; 
  }

I don't know at what point it was fixed, but later iOS phones work without the transform tag. I don't know if it's the iOS version, or the phone.

As most iOS devices are usually on the most recent iOS version, it's pretty safe with go with a weird work around - such as using the transform tag, rather than building in a quirky detection routine for the sake of less than 1% of users.

Update:

After thinking about this answer further, this is just another way of doing this by platform for ionic5+:

.TS

import {Platform } from '@ionic/angular';

constructor(
public platform: Platform 
) 
{  
    // This next bit is so that the CSS is shown correctly for each platform    

    platform.ready().then(() => {
    if (this.platform.is('android')) {
        console.log("running on Android device!");
        this.css_iOS = false;
    }
    if (this.platform.is('ios')) {
        console.log("running on iOS device!");
        this.css_iOS = true;
    }     
    if (this.platform.is('ipad')) {
        console.log("running on iOS device!");
        this.css_iOS = true;
    }
    });
}
css_iOS: boolean = false;

.HTML

<style *ngIf="css_iOS">
    .small_player {
      position: -webkit-sticky !important;
    }
    .large_player {
      position: -webkit-sticky !important;
    }
    </style>
    
    
    <style>
    .small_player {
    float: left;
      bottom: 0;
      width: 100%;
      position: fixed;
      background-color: white;
      border-top: black 1px solid;    
      height: 4rem;
      z-index: 100;
      /*transform: translate3d(0,0,0);*/
    }
    
    .large_player {
    float: left;
      bottom: 0;
      width: 100%;
      position: fixed;
      background-color: white;
      border-top: black 1px solid;    
      height: 14rem;
      z-index: 100;
      /*transform: translate3d(0,0,0);*/
    }
    </style>